$250 - $499

Prices may vary in club and online
Sort by|
Cushion-Cut Blue Topaz Cocktail Ring in 14K Gold
Sponsored
current price $949.00
Cushion-Cut Blue Topaz Cocktail Ring in 14K Gold
4.6 out of 5 Stars. 10 reviews
Available for Shipping
Morganite and Diamond Accent Double Halo Ring in 14K Gold
Sponsored
current price $879.00
Morganite and Diamond Accent Double Halo Ring in 14K Gold
4.1875 out of 5 Stars. 64 reviews
Available for Shipping
0.17 CT. T.W. Round Cut Single Row Diamond Mens Band in 14K Gold
current price $1,069.00
0.17 CT. T.W. Round Cut Single Row Diamond Mens Band in 14K Gold
5 out of 5 Stars. 12 reviews
Available for Shipping
0.25 CT. T.W. Diamond Eternity Band in 14K Gold
current price $399.00
0.25 CT. T.W. Diamond Eternity Band in 14K Gold
4.2778 out of 5 Stars. 18 reviews
Available for Shipping
Freshwater 11-12mm Pearl Station Necklace and Stud Earring Set
Freshwater 11-12mm Pearl Station Necklace and Stud Earring Set
current price $299.00
Freshwater 11-12mm Pearl Station Necklace and Stud Earring Set
4.3704 out of 5 Stars. 27 reviews
Available for Shipping
9-9.5 mm Round Cultured Freshwater Pearl and Blue Sapphire with 0.11 CT. T.W. Diamond Earrings in 14K Gold
9-9.5 mm Round Cultured Freshwater Pearl and Blue Sapphire with 0.11 CT. T.W. Diamond Earrings in 14K Gold
Sponsored
current price $699.00
9-9.5 mm Round Cultured Freshwater Pearl and Blue Sapphire with 0.11 CT. T.W. Diamond Earrings in 14K Gold
3.75 out of 5 Stars. 8 reviews
Available for Shipping
Love Knot Stick Drop Stud Earrings in 14K Gold
Love Knot Stick Drop Stud Earrings in 14K Gold
current price $349.00
From $349.00
Love Knot Stick Drop Stud Earrings in 14K Gold
4.5 out of 5 Stars. 8 reviews
Available for Shipping , Pickup or Delivery
Treated Solitaire Gemstone Ring in 14K Gold
current price $849.00
Options from $579.00 – $849.00
Treated Solitaire Gemstone Ring in 14K Gold
4.4651 out of 5 Stars. 43 reviews
Available for Shipping
Tree Of Life Mother Of Pearl Ring 14K Gold
Tree Of Life Mother Of Pearl Ring 14K Gold
current price $429.00
Tree Of Life Mother Of Pearl Ring 14K Gold
4.7778 out of 5 Stars. 45 reviews
Available for Shipping
Morganite and Diamond Accent Cocktail Ring in 14K Gold
Sponsored
current price $749.00
Morganite and Diamond Accent Cocktail Ring in 14K Gold
4.0952 out of 5 Stars. 21 reviews
Available for Shipping
0.23 CT. T.W. Round Diamond Stud Earrings in 14K Gold
current price $299.00
0.23 CT. T.W. Round Diamond Stud Earrings in 14K Gold
4.4643 out of 5 Stars. 28 reviews
Available for Shipping
0.23 CT. T.W. Baguette and Round Diamond Pendant in 14K Gold
0.23 CT. T.W. Baguette and Round Diamond Pendant in 14K Gold
current price $399.00
0.23 CT. T.W. Baguette and Round Diamond Pendant in 14K Gold
4.0952 out of 5 Stars. 21 reviews
Available for Shipping
Love Knot Ring in 14K Yellow Gold
current price $435.00
Love Knot Ring in 14K Yellow Gold
4.75 out of 5 Stars. 8 reviews
Available for Shipping
Vintage Diamond Band in 14K Gold
current price $549.00
Vintage Diamond Band in 14K Gold
5 out of 5 Stars. 14 reviews
Available for Shipping
Oval Black Onyx Ring in 14K Gold
current price $325.00
Oval Black Onyx Ring in 14K Gold
4.3153 out of 5 Stars. 111 reviews
Available for Shipping
8X6MM Oval Aquamarine Ring with Diamonds in 14K Gold
current price $819.00
8X6MM Oval Aquamarine Ring with Diamonds in 14K Gold
4.4483 out of 5 Stars. 29 reviews
Available for Shipping
Pink Amethyst Cushion Cut Ring in 14K Gold
current price $899.00
Pink Amethyst Cushion Cut Ring in 14K Gold
4.3636 out of 5 Stars. 33 reviews
Available for Shipping
0.23 CT. T.W. Round Cut Diamond Pendant Necklace in 14K Gold
current price $349.00
From $349.00
0.23 CT. T.W. Round Cut Diamond Pendant Necklace in 14K Gold
4.1667 out of 5 Stars. 18 reviews
Available for Shipping , Pickup or Delivery
Virgin Mary Oval Pendant Necklace in 14K Gold
current price $349.00
From $349.00
Virgin Mary Oval Pendant Necklace in 14K Gold
4.3333 out of 5 Stars. 21 reviews
Available for Shipping , Pickup or Delivery
Prasiolite Quartz Promise Ring in 14K Gold
current price $639.00
Prasiolite Quartz Promise Ring in 14K Gold
4.5 out of 5 Stars. 6 reviews
Available for Shipping
Cushion Cut Gemstone and 0.15 CT. T.W. Halo Diamond Stud Earrings in 14K Gold
current price $279.00
Options from $279.00 – $429.00
Cushion Cut Gemstone and 0.15 CT. T.W. Halo Diamond Stud Earrings in 14K Gold
4.6087 out of 5 Stars. 23 reviews
Available for Shipping
0.81CT. TW. Black & White Diamond Bracelet in Stainless Steel
0.81CT. TW. Black & White Diamond Bracelet in Stainless Steel
current price $339.00
0.81CT. TW. Black & White Diamond Bracelet in Stainless Steel
4 out of 5 Stars. 7 reviews
Available for Shipping
Lab Created Round Cut Sapphire Necklace in Sterling Silver
current price $219.00
From $219.00
Lab Created Round Cut Sapphire Necklace in Sterling Silver
4.0556 out of 5 Stars. 18 reviews
Available for Shipping , Pickup or Delivery
Lab Created White Sapphire Eternity Band in 14K Gold
current price $499.00
Lab Created White Sapphire Eternity Band in 14K Gold
3.3333 out of 5 Stars. 21 reviews
Available for Shipping
0.25 CT. T.W. Round Cut Script Diamond Pendant Necklace in 14K Gold
current price $749.00
0.25 CT. T.W. Round Cut Script Diamond Pendant Necklace in 14K Gold
Available for Shipping
Double Curve Hoop Earrings in 14K Gold
current price $599.00
Options from $599.00 – $649.00
Double Curve Hoop Earrings in 14K Gold
4.4568 out of 5 Stars. 278 reviews
Available for Shipping
Disney 0.23 CT. T.W. Diamond Mickey Mouse Necklace in 14K Gold
current price $459.00
Disney 0.23 CT. T.W. Diamond Mickey Mouse Necklace in 14K Gold
Available for Shipping
Disney 0.19 CT. T.W. Diamond Minnie Mouse Necklace in 14K Gold
current price $429.00
Disney 0.19 CT. T.W. Diamond Minnie Mouse Necklace in 14K Gold
Available for Shipping
0.23 CT. T.W. Diamond Double Heart Infinity Pendant in 14K Gold
current price $369.00
0.23 CT. T.W. Diamond Double Heart Infinity Pendant in 14K Gold
4.5455 out of 5 Stars. 11 reviews
Available for Shipping
0.11 CT. T.W. Round Cut Semi Eternity Mens Diamond Band in 14K Gold
current price $999.00
0.11 CT. T.W. Round Cut Semi Eternity Mens Diamond Band in 14K Gold
4.3333 out of 5 Stars. 9 reviews
Available for Shipping
Oval Cut Lab Created Gemstone Halo Tennis Necklace in Sterling Silver
current price $349.00
Options from $349.00 – $499.00
Oval Cut Lab Created Gemstone Halo Tennis Necklace in Sterling Silver
4.4545 out of 5 Stars. 11 reviews
Available for Shipping , Pickup or Delivery
Round Cut White Sapphire Infinity Band in 14K Gold
current price $579.00
Round Cut White Sapphire Infinity Band in 14K Gold
4.7778 out of 5 Stars. 9 reviews
Available for Shipping
White Sapphire & Diamond Accent Three Stone Halo Ring in 14K Gold
current price $699.00
White Sapphire & Diamond Accent Three Stone Halo Ring in 14K Gold
3.9 out of 5 Stars. 10 reviews
Available for Shipping
Cushion Cut Gemstone & 0.18 CT.T.W. Halo Diamond Ring in 14K Gold
current price $335.00
Cushion Cut Gemstone & 0.18 CT.T.W. Halo Diamond Ring in 14K Gold
4.2105 out of 5 Stars. 19 reviews
Available for Shipping
White Cultured Freshwater Pearl Strand Necklace with 14k Gold Clasp
current price $99.00
Options from $99.00 – $375.00
White Cultured Freshwater Pearl Strand Necklace with 14k Gold Clasp
4.2394 out of 5 Stars. 71 reviews
Available for Shipping
Ankle Bracelet in 14K Gold
current price $565.00
Options from $265.00 – $739.00
Ankle Bracelet in 14K Gold
4.6026 out of 5 Stars. 78 reviews
Available for Shipping
Freshwater Cultured Pearl Pendant with 0.11 CT. T.W. Diamonds in 14K Gold
Freshwater Cultured Pearl Pendant with 0.11 CT. T.W. Diamonds in 14K Gold
current price $499.00
Freshwater Cultured Pearl Pendant with 0.11 CT. T.W. Diamonds in 14K Gold
4.875 out of 5 Stars. 16 reviews
Available for Shipping
Paperclip & Cable Chain Bracelet with Padlock Charm in 14K Gold
current price $499.00
From $499.00
Paperclip & Cable Chain Bracelet with Padlock Charm in 14K Gold
4.0476 out of 5 Stars. 21 reviews
Available for Shipping , Pickup or Delivery
Wedding Band Hoop Earrings in 14K Gold
current price $465.00
Options from $375.00 – $629.00
Wedding Band Hoop Earrings in 14K Gold
5 out of 5 Stars. 1 reviews
Available for Shipping
Tanzanite Tennis Bracelet in Sterling Silver
current price $279.00
Tanzanite Tennis Bracelet in Sterling Silver
3.8438 out of 5 Stars. 32 reviews
Available for Shipping
Solitaire Gemstone Pendant Necklace in 14K Gold
current price $419.00
Options from $329.00 – $469.00
Solitaire Gemstone Pendant Necklace in 14K Gold
4.6875 out of 5 Stars. 16 reviews
Available for Shipping
Graduated Gemstone Tennis Necklace in Sterling Silver
current price $568.00
Graduated Gemstone Tennis Necklace in Sterling Silver
Available for Shipping
Round Cut Semi Eternity Diamond Band in 14K Gold
current price $1,199.00
Round Cut Semi Eternity Diamond Band in 14K Gold
4.45 out of 5 Stars. 60 reviews
Available for Shipping
0.05 CT. T.W. Round Cut Single Row Mens Diamond Band in 14K Gold
current price $869.00
0.05 CT. T.W. Round Cut Single Row Mens Diamond Band in 14K Gold
4.7273 out of 5 Stars. 11 reviews
Available for Shipping
Black Freshwater Pearl Strand Necklace
current price $294.00
Options from $227.00 – $473.00
Black Freshwater Pearl Strand Necklace
4.56 out of 5 Stars. 25 reviews
Available for Shipping
Panther Chain Bracelet in 14K Gold
current price $1,195.00
Options from $815.00 – $1,195.00
Panther Chain Bracelet in 14K Gold
4.5 out of 5 Stars. 12 reviews
Available for Shipping
Cushion Checkerboard-Cut Madeira Citrine Leverback Earrings in 14K Yellow Gold
Cushion Checkerboard-Cut Madeira Citrine Leverback Earrings in 14K Yellow Gold
current price $849.00
Cushion Checkerboard-Cut Madeira Citrine Leverback Earrings in 14K Yellow Gold
Available for Shipping

Frequently Asked Questions

Is 14K gold better for gifts than 10K gold?

Can I find certified diamonds in this price range?

What is the benefit of a "hinged" bangle?

How should I care about gemstone jewelry?

Is lab-grown diamond jewelry a good investment for a gift?

About Jewelry under $500 - Shop Jewelry by Price

Elevate Your Gifting Experience

Celebrate milestones and create lasting memories with the Gifting Jewelry $250 - $499 collection at Sam’s Club. This carefully curated range offers the perfect balance of prestige and value, featuring solid 14K Gold Designs and higher-carat Diamond jewelry. Whether you are marking an anniversary, a promotion, or a significant birthday, these pieces offer the weight and brilliance of professional-grade fine jewelry.

From Gold Staples to Diamond Essentials

Our mid-range luxury collection is designed to provide high-impact style for every personality. Explore our specialized categories to find a gift that speaks volumes:

Timeless Gold Staples:

Brilliant Diamond Essentials:

  • Sparkling Studs & Hoops: Shop our Diamond Earrings and shimmering hoops. These pieces utilize higher-quality stones to ensure maximum fire and brilliance.

Precious Gemstone Rings:

Modern Lab-Grown Diamonds:

  • Advanced Brilliance: Explore Lab-Grown Diamond Pendants that provide a larger look and exceptional clarity, allowing you to maximize your $500 budget.

Gift Selection: Fine Jewelry $250 - $499

Model Category Best For Top Recommendation
14K Gold Chains Signature daily style; substantial gold weight and unique design for everyday wear. Three Bead Necklace Earring Set
Diamond Studs Anniversaries and birthdays; essential diamond solitaires that offer timeless sparkle and prestige. 1/2 CT TW Diamond Studs
Gemstone Luxury Milestone celebrations; high-end precious stones like sapphires set in intricate gold settings. Sapphire & Diamond Halo
Gold Bangles Sophisticated wristwear; high-polish 14K gold bangles that provide a structured, polished look. 14K High-Polished Bangle

Why Buy Mid-Range Jewelry from Sam’s Club?

  • Wholesale Value: Our jewelry collection offers quality at prices that reflect our warehouse mission.
  • Ethically Sourced: All diamonds are conflict-free and adhere to the Kimberley Process, ensuring your gift represents beauty and responsibility.
  • Independent Grading: Most diamond items in the $400+ range include reports from IGI or GIA, providing professional verification of your stone's quality.
  • Plus Member Exclusive: Get access to a variety of fine jewelry collection and exclusive members’ only pricing.