I have been buying Member's Mark Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, 40 oz., 2 pk. for a very long time. We love it, well loved it anyways. The last few months we have been getting crap products. It started with one that was half oil. Returned that one. This last shipment they have been thinner than usual. I do not know if it is a quality control issue or they are sitting in a hat warehouse and have separated. Could be a combination of both but I think it is a QC issue. EIther way we are going back to the Aldi brand peanut butter. What a shame.

I am on second jar and had to write this. When you open the jars its a mess of oil spilling out . Try to stir this big jar that says NO STIR! My first jar that I just finished was all hard on the bottom because the oil I tried to stir in did not all the way to the bottom! Will not buy again.

OK so let me be real here, I am a life long Jif fan and would never consider another brand but since the Jif recall I had to return my peanut butter & needed a replacement and literally this is the only peanut butte that was left in the store so since I eat peanut butter every day I bought it and I am so glad I did ! OMG it is better than Jif ! Less, salt, fat and creamier and yummier! I am switching to this brand from now on and best of all t is a better value !

I’ve been using jiff forever so, when the recall happened, I had an unopened 2 pack that had to go back to Sam’s. Based on some if the reviews, I decided to give the member’s mark brand a try. It’s very tasty, spreads easily, and a bit less money to buy. I’m really glad there’s an alternative to jiff at Sam’s!

We love this peanut butter! Yes, it has sugar. Yes, it has palm oil. When we feel like being ultra-virtuous, we grind peanuts at the health food store. This is not that kind of peanut butter! This peanut butter is a very tasty option for those who don't want the gmo hydrogenated oils found in standard peanut butters and don't want the health food store stuff every day. Plus it makes terrific pb cookies :)

I used to buy this, believing it was a better coice than the peanut butter that has a lot of added sugar and other ingredients. However, its right there on the front label, "Peanut Butter SPREAD". That extra word makes all the difference. Peanut butter should be simply peanuts and salt, maybe honey and sugar. This has Palm oil. If you are under the illusion that this is a "healthier" option then think again.

Natural peanut butter should be just that! Ingredients should be: ground peanuts and nothing more. Added oil means the good peanut oil was removed and sold separately and if we want sweet peanut butter we can add our own honey, not the added sugar, which is probably refined. Still a step above Jif, Skippy, Peter Pan, etc. who use hydrogenated oils.

I specifically purchased this product because the labeling indicated no stir. Imagine my surprise when I opened a jar only to discover at least an inch of oil covering the pb. Due to the height of the jar it was impossible to reincorporate the oil to the very bottom without removing the contents into a mixing bowl then transferring the incorporated product back to the jar, a messy procedure resulting in some loss of product. For the record, the product was transported directly to my residence and promptly placed in a temperature controlled pantry. 2nd jar was donated to a food bank with a post it note indicating it isn't NO STIR.

I have to really be in the mood to eat peanut butter but I bought this and I can't put it down! It's very creamy, tastes great and unlike other peanut butters, it didn't get thick and hard to spread as I reached the bottom of the container. I'll be buying again!

I was excited to see that Sam's was selling "natural" Peanut Butter in our store...until... I read the ingredients! "Natural" Peanut Butter doe NOT have Sugar added and does NOT have any Oil Added. Peanuts have plenty of natural oil and sugars in them already....naturally. I am Totally DISAPPOINTED!