I was disappointed to see that Sam's was no longer selling Natural Skippy Peanut Butter in our store anymore. This "Natural" Peanut Butter product has added sugar & the peanut oil removed and replaced by palm oil, which has saturated fat! I am Totally DISAPPOINTED! Bring back the Natural Skippy Peanut Butter!!!

I previously rated this PB a 5. Great taste, price, etc. the best part was this natural PB didn’t separate. Unfortunately, the last few jars I bought, I find it separates and the oil sits on top. Loved it before but probably won’t buy it in the future.

Pros: Taste, Price, no partially-hydrogenated vegetable oil Cons: contains sugar. I eat a lot of peanut butter, so I thought I'd try this because of the price. I just wish it didn't have sugar added, since I try not to eat anything with added sugars. It's a disappointment to those who are trying for low-carb meals.

This is not the best example of “natural” peanut butter. Natural peanut butter is made with 100% peanuts and nothing else other than a little salt. There is no added sugar or an alternate oil. Peanut oil is a healthy nut oil and that has been removed and a different oil has been added. Adding sugar to peanut butter is not only unnecessary but actually reduces the flavor of peanuts, which several other reviewers have noted. My husband purchased this peanut butter on his last trip to Sams Club without reading the ingredients, based on the word “natural” on the label. He was very disappointed when he tasted it. Members Mark, Sams Clubs house brand, has many good products. Unfortunately we do not feel this is one of them.

This sure is some good peanut butter. I bought 6 of them. My girlfriend has already consumed 2 jars in the past two days. She is like the Franks Red Hot old lady in the commercial. “She puts that sh*t on everything.” She just now cut up 3 bananas and is spreading this peanut butter on each slice. I asked to try a piece and she said no.

No Stir? Every time I opened the jar I had to stir this peanut butter spread. I even tried mixing it up in my stand mixer then separating it into smaller jars. Whether it was week or just a day, I had to stir before use. The taste is acceptable, but it's messy and inconvenient. I won't be purchasing this product again.

I was interested in this product until I, too, read the ingredients. I will stick with the truly natural product where there's just peanuts and salt, nothing else. I will put up with having to stir in the peanut oil before putting it into the refrigerator and after that no oil separation.

We have bought this product before and we liked it. However this purchase was horrible. So much oil that it was hard to stir without it sloshing out of the container. I originally thought we got a bad one so I opened the other jar and it was the same. Did you change the recipe or just a heavy handed oil distributor?

While shopping at Sam's I notice a new Peanut Butter at a good price. I bought it and brought it home. It reminded me of the old Oxhart Creamy Peanut Butter from my youth. I tried it the first time and thought, it's a little different I'll have to get use to it. The second time I tried it, I thought, it doesn't have much peanut butter taste. My wife tried it and she hated it. I tired to like it having it two more times. The last time, I looked for the second jar of it and put them together for return to the store. It just doesn't have much peanut butter flavor. I wouldn't recommend this peanut butter to anyone who has ever tasted, Peanut Butter!!

I have been buying this peanut regularly for about four years and the quality has been consistent. I have never experienced it being runny or oily that some reviewers report. Also, if you do not know what "natural" means on a label, it means nothing artificial was added during processing and the product was minimally processed. Palm Oil and sugar are natural ingredients. They are not artificial. If you want to know what's in it read the ingredient list. I do not add sugar to anything or eat candy, ice cream, etc. but I will say that 3 grams of sugar in a serving (2 Tbsp) is not a lot. Also palm oil is MUCH healthier than the hydrogenated oils that you will find in Skippy and Jif. If there is no oil added to peanut butter it can be very hard to stir.