After cheating on this peanut butter and trying other brands, I had to come back. The consistency, flavor, and richness was hard to beat. Having an extra tub in the pantry is also convenient. But paired with honeycrisp apples or a slightly underripe banana is my favorite way to eat this peanut butter!

I’ve been using jiff forever so, when the recall happened, I had an unopened 2 pack that had to go back to Sam’s. Based on some if the reviews, I decided to give the member’s mark brand a try. It’s very tasty, spreads easily, and a bit less money to buy. I’m really glad there’s an alternative to jiff at Sam’s!

We have bought this product before and we liked it. However this purchase was horrible. So much oil that it was hard to stir without it sloshing out of the container. I originally thought we got a bad one so I opened the other jar and it was the same. Did you change the recipe or just a heavy handed oil distributor?

I specifically purchased this product because the labeling indicated no stir. Imagine my surprise when I opened a jar only to discover at least an inch of oil covering the pb. Due to the height of the jar it was impossible to reincorporate the oil to the very bottom without removing the contents into a mixing bowl then transferring the incorporated product back to the jar, a messy procedure resulting in some loss of product. For the record, the product was transported directly to my residence and promptly placed in a temperature controlled pantry. 2nd jar was donated to a food bank with a post it note indicating it isn't NO STIR.

I was disappointed to see that Sam's was no longer selling Natural Skippy Peanut Butter in our store anymore. This "Natural" Peanut Butter product has added sugar & the peanut oil removed and replaced by palm oil, which has saturated fat! I am Totally DISAPPOINTED! Bring back the Natural Skippy Peanut Butter!!!

I was interested in this product until I, too, read the ingredients. I will stick with the truly natural product where there's just peanuts and salt, nothing else. I will put up with having to stir in the peanut oil before putting it into the refrigerator and after that no oil separation.

I used to buy this, believing it was a better coice than the peanut butter that has a lot of added sugar and other ingredients. However, its right there on the front label, "Peanut Butter SPREAD". That extra word makes all the difference. Peanut butter should be simply peanuts and salt, maybe honey and sugar. This has Palm oil. If you are under the illusion that this is a "healthier" option then think again.

I previously rated this PB a 5. Great taste, price, etc. the best part was this natural PB didn’t separate. Unfortunately, the last few jars I bought, I find it separates and the oil sits on top. Loved it before but probably won’t buy it in the future.

Pros: Taste, Price, no partially-hydrogenated vegetable oil Cons: contains sugar. I eat a lot of peanut butter, so I thought I'd try this because of the price. I just wish it didn't have sugar added, since I try not to eat anything with added sugars. It's a disappointment to those who are trying for low-carb meals.

Used to LOVE it but one of my recent shipments was soo dry and couldn’t stir and was a dripping grease mess. Thought it was just that one but it was with the next one too. Not returnable as it was a greasy mess after opening the seal on my counter so I had to chuck.