Really looking forward to this but the consistency is off. I failed to read the label first and after discovering it has PALM OIL I now know why. Palm oil is barely passable in body lotion so no clue why they have decided to put it into food when even wild animals wont eat it It stays thick which is it's selling point

This is not a natural peanut butter. This contains added sugar and oil. I bought it in a hurry, not realizing it's not actually natural. Natural peanut butter is meant to NOT contain added sugar and oils and sometimes even salt. It is very misleading and shouldn't be allowed to be labeled natural.

We have been using this product for several years now. The flavor is good, however, in recent months it seems to be much more runny and oily than when we have bought it previously. Thin enough that it will drip off of a sandwich, almost a syrup. Perhaps it is just one batch, but if the problem continues, we will no longer buy it.

As a life-long Jif devotee, I'll admit I was skeptical of a "generic" peanut butter. This Members Mark PB is better than Jif and the price can't be beat. The flavor is great, not too sugary and just the right balance of salt and creaminess. This is our go-to brand of PB now and I have no reason to go back to Jif. Thanks Sam's Club!

Used to be wonderful but in the last year it has gotten so runny at the top and solid at the bottom. They say it doesn't need to be stirred, but that just isn't the case anymore. And when you stir it, it slops outside of the container and makes a mess. Need to take it to home depot and let the paint department shake it up!

The label on the jar says, “natural- no stir” but it MUST be stirred and it is messy to try to incorporate the oil on top into the peanut butter at the bottom of the jar, which causes it to be dry and lumpy. Although I have bought this brand for a couple of years, I think I will return to Jiff

Jif was removed from the shelves due to a quality problem that Sam's never notified it's customers about. I purchased this thinking it would be a good substitute. I was wrong. While the taste is OK, the consistency and viscosity sub-par. It separates in the "jar" requiring stirring before use. It becomes almost a liquid and runs off the sides of warm toast. I wonder how it would affect baked goods. This is three time deal for us; first, last and only.

I love most Member's Mark products, so I decided to try their creamy peanut butter. Wow, it tastes great and is very creamy. However, after scraping my tongue, brushing my tongue with toothpaste and gargling with mouthwash, I could not get rid of the taste on my tongue and in my mouth. I will not buy this peanut butter again.

This peanut butter is good if you are just eating it straight but if you cook with it the oil in the peanut butter separates out and ruins whatever you are making. I made brownies first and though maybe I had done something wrong because there was an oil slick on top as they cooked but then I made no bakes and the same thing happened! Ok to eat straight but will ruin anything you try to bake!

This peanut butter has much less taste than the major brand I usually buy (Jiff) at Sam's Club. It is a thin, VERY oily "spread." Although "Natural -- No Stir" is printed on the label, it requires a great deal of stirring (though stirring can't blend the palm oil with the peanut butter) and it doesn't taste much like peanuts.. And I've never seen real peanut butter that contains palm oil (which hides the peanut taste). I bought this product because it was the only peanut butter available at the SC store. I won't buy it again and will probably throw away the opened jar and (hopefully) give away the other jar. Disappointing product, at any price.