I don't review products but I had to on this one. I have been burned by store brand peanut butter and was so skeptical on trying this. My husband and kids eat a large jar of peanut butter every two weeks, so I was looking for lower cost option since we were going through so much. I picked this up and my husband can't put it down. He says he loves it better than Jif that he used to swear by. I tried it this morning and the taste is phenomenal. I would highly recommend for anyone that is on the fence about purchasing.

The only reason for the low star is that on the label it brags to be "no stir" however everything I use it I find myself having to stir the peanut butter because the oils seep to the top. One time it happened within 30 minutes between two sandwiches. Taste is good and if you don't mind stirring it is a good peanut butter.

This is not "Natural" in the way they lead you to believe. It contains added sugar. And because the oil is palm oil, that means they removed the peanut oil. This is basically no different than Jif. If you look at Smuckers natural, you'll see it contains ONE ingredient. PEANUTS.

Jif was removed from the shelves due to a quality problem that Sam's never notified it's customers about. I purchased this thinking it would be a good substitute. I was wrong. While the taste is OK, the consistency and viscosity sub-par. It separates in the "jar" requiring stirring before use. It becomes almost a liquid and runs off the sides of warm toast. I wonder how it would affect baked goods. This is three time deal for us; first, last and only.

I got this to make cookies, since my regular brand was on recall. I was very surprised to find the taste was equal to my old brand, and it worked equally well in my wife's cookie dough. The grandkids loved it on sandwiches, and said it was better than the name brand.

I didn't realize this was "natural" until I opened it and saw oil sitting on top. I don't buy the natural in any brand because don't like having to stir it before each use. I had nothing to lose because of the money back guarantee so I got out a heavier serving spoon and mixed it thoroughly - including the hard stuff at the bottom. I was surprised that I didn't have to mix it again - not even a little bit. It also tastes great!

Used to be wonderful but in the last year it has gotten so runny at the top and solid at the bottom. They say it doesn't need to be stirred, but that just isn't the case anymore. And when you stir it, it slops outside of the container and makes a mess. Need to take it to home depot and let the paint department shake it up!

From the time I purchased and opened up this peanut butter the “No Stir” is a lie. First time opening the oil was all in top and spilled. Every time I open it has to be stirred. I should have returned it. I am going to donate since I hate dealing with stirring.

Disappointed after purchasing this peanut butter, I should've read the label more carefully instead of zoning in on its good price. Peanut butter spread, never heard of such. Also, how can this be no stir with an inch of oil on top? It's Jif next time for me no matter what it costs.

We really loved this as it is comparable to JIF natural peanut butter. It was a better deal too as JIF is $3.59 for 16 oz and this is about the same price for 40 oz., Not only is this not available in the store or even able to be ordered, but the store shelf labeling has been completely removed which would imply that this product has been removed from the Sam's Club product line-up. This is disappointing. I hope they bring it back.