Used to be wonderful but in the last year it has gotten so runny at the top and solid at the bottom. They say it doesn't need to be stirred, but that just isn't the case anymore. And when you stir it, it slops outside of the container and makes a mess. Need to take it to home depot and let the paint department shake it up!

I didn't realize this was "natural" until I opened it and saw oil sitting on top. I don't buy the natural in any brand because don't like having to stir it before each use. I had nothing to lose because of the money back guarantee so I got out a heavier serving spoon and mixed it thoroughly - including the hard stuff at the bottom. I was surprised that I didn't have to mix it again - not even a little bit. It also tastes great!

This is not "Natural" in the way they lead you to believe. It contains added sugar. And because the oil is palm oil, that means they removed the peanut oil. This is basically no different than Jif. If you look at Smuckers natural, you'll see it contains ONE ingredient. PEANUTS.

Our whole family loves this peanut butter. It is actually a no stir natural peanut butter. We’ve tried others that need to be stirred every time you open the jar. That is not the case with this brand. One jar last us less than two weeks. It tastes better than the big name brands and has better ingredients.

I don't know why but when the lockdowns happened with covid, they changed the recipe of this peanut butter or something. It's really runny now. Would probably be good for cooking sauces with but for pb&j /sandwiches it's terrible now. Taste is good but texture sucks.

My husband is Mr. Peanut Butter - an *authority." He declares this to be the BEST. AND - it's natural but not all separated and oily and yucky. Doubts you'll find better at such a good price. (Our doggo loves it as well, and she's a picky lil' brat.)

As a life-long Jif devotee, I'll admit I was skeptical of a "generic" peanut butter. This Members Mark PB is better than Jif and the price can't be beat. The flavor is great, not too sugary and just the right balance of salt and creaminess. This is our go-to brand of PB now and I have no reason to go back to Jif. Thanks Sam's Club!

I read the ingredients and realized it wasn't a true natural PB before buying. I still gave it a whirl based on the low price for sandwiches and whatnot. It's just not good. Weird taste, gritty, not peanut buttery. If I'm going to eat not actual natural PB, I'll just stick with Jif from now on.

Tastes good, but quite runny. It ran out of my kid's PB&J. Not a mess I want to deal with every day with a three year old. However, it's perfect for dipping (i.e. apple slices, pretzel rods) and drizzling. True to its name, it does not require stirring.

This peanut butter has much less taste than the major brand I usually buy (Jiff) at Sam's Club. It is a thin, VERY oily "spread." Although "Natural -- No Stir" is printed on the label, it requires a great deal of stirring (though stirring can't blend the palm oil with the peanut butter) and it doesn't taste much like peanuts.. And I've never seen real peanut butter that contains palm oil (which hides the peanut taste). I bought this product because it was the only peanut butter available at the SC store. I won't buy it again and will probably throw away the opened jar and (hopefully) give away the other jar. Disappointing product, at any price.