I purchased this for the first time yesterday-I was certainly a skeptic so I made my husband and children do a "taste-test" since we are strictly a Jiff family. My family absolutely LOVED this Peanut Butter! It is much smoother/creamier than Jiff and the flavor is way better. I couldn't stop eating it, I dipped apples and banana slices in it and my daughter had a sandwich as well. The price is also less than Jiff and you get more servings in each jar as well. If you are concerned about calories, this has less than Jiff, it's a win-win! I will be switching indefinitely!

My family has been using this PB exclusively for several years now. We are huge PB lovers and this stuff is amazing! Whether its for baking, pb&j's, pb & banana smoothies, on top of waffles, etc. it's just soooo good! And best of all, the ingredients are much healthier than typical PB but without that weird texture or oily soupy stuff on top. My parents love it, my sister and her family love it, and I've even turned die hard fans of "other" popular brands on to it.

This pb has no oil to stir but it is creamy and you can tell there's oil in it. If you like the pb that has to be stirred, you'll like this. Where the other top name brands are creamy, they are loaded with preservatives that keep them creamy without oil that separates. I just love this Peanut butter. I'll buy again and again.

This peanut butter has much less taste than the major brand I usually buy (Jiff) at Sam's Club. It is a thin, VERY oily "spread." Although "Natural -- No Stir" is printed on the label, it requires a great deal of stirring (though stirring can't blend the palm oil with the peanut butter) and it doesn't taste much like peanuts.. And I've never seen real peanut butter that contains palm oil (which hides the peanut taste). I bought this product because it was the only peanut butter available at the SC store. I won't buy it again and will probably throw away the opened jar and (hopefully) give away the other jar. Disappointing product, at any price.

This peanut butter is delicious: not too salty, not too sweet. Surprise! It tastes like peanuts and reminds me of the peanut butter we made from scratch while living in West Africa. We ran out recently and I couldn't get to the big city to stop by Sam's so I bought another brand from our local store. Yuck! Not only was it extremely sweet and salty, it was also grainy. And if nothing else convinces you this peanut butter is worth a try, this might. My thrifty husband even agreed we could throw out that grainy other brand now that I'be been able to restock with Member's Mark.

We really loved this as it is comparable to JIF natural peanut butter. It was a better deal too as JIF is $3.59 for 16 oz and this is about the same price for 40 oz., Not only is this not available in the store or even able to be ordered, but the store shelf labeling has been completely removed which would imply that this product has been removed from the Sam's Club product line-up. This is disappointing. I hope they bring it back.

My husband is Mr. Peanut Butter - an *authority." He declares this to be the BEST. AND - it's natural but not all separated and oily and yucky. Doubts you'll find better at such a good price. (Our doggo loves it as well, and she's a picky lil' brat.)

Call me crazy, but I don't think every food needs to be sweet. Truly all-natural PB is so versatile and healthy. Sadly most Americans associate PB only with sweet, but there is a world of tasty foods out there that use PB, and there is absolutely zero need for sugar.

This is the best pb I've ever had. The taste is phenomenal! Love that it spreads so easily without tearing bread. It has to be stirred periodically but no big deal. We also love it because it's so much easier to get our dog to take her pills. It doesn't stick to one's mouth like other brands. Again, the flavor is fantastic!!

When you first open it the PB is really runny, when you get to the bottom it is so stiff you can hardly get it out of the jar. So with the second jar, I have tried to stir it and that's just messy. It was an okay substitute when you couldn't get Jiff but I won't be purchasing this again unless I have no choice.