Better than I expected but it does separate! It says it doesn't separate like other natural brands but not true! But if you don't mind the separating, you will be happy with the peanut butter.

The orders we've gotten since spring have all been oily. The peanut butter separates, and it's gross. I used to love this. I assumed it was weather related, but it's cooled off now and it's still a problem.

All I get to do with this peanut butter is stir it. Drug myself through the first jar to open the second jar and find the oil all at the top. Won’t even begin to use the second jar. Going back to JIF.

This peanut butter tastes good but needs storing due to the oil separating. This makes for quite the mess especially when the container is full. I won’t buy this brand again.

My husband loves his natural Peanut Butter. When he is looking for a late night snack it is often his go to! A smooth stroke of peanut butter on some whole grain bread… yummy!

You have to stir a lot. Not sure why it says "No Stir" on the label. It is also quite runny, thin peanut butter even after stirring said "no stir" peanut butter.

We like this better than most brand name spreads. After reading the label, I have but one question…… what is the country of origin? Distributed by Sam’s club but produced by ……??? Thank you

This is great peanut butter and it has less ingredients than JIF or other brands and it's cheaper. I will continue buying this. My family also loves the Members Mark Strawberry Preserves

Within a couple days of purchase I opened one and it had completely separated. Oils in peanut butter will leach out some over time and it will mix back in but not with this stuff. Appeared as though all of the oils had come out and wouldn't mix back in. The solids below the oil slick on top were hard, could mix it.

I didn't realize this was "natural" until I opened it and saw oil sitting on top. I don't buy the natural in any brand because don't like having to stir it before each use. I had nothing to lose because of the money back guarantee so I got out a heavier serving spoon and mixed it thoroughly - including the hard stuff at the bottom. I was surprised that I didn't have to mix it again - not even a little bit. It also tastes great!