For those of you who say this is just as good as JIF, you must not be eating the same JIF that I do. It's not even close, at all, period. Also a hint: if it says "no stir" on the label, you're gonna have to stir it. I don't even know how Sam's gets away with that. Tolerable, at best.

It used to be that "natural peanut butter" contained only peanuts, and maybe salt. During the anti-transfat craze a few years ago, many companies started selling "natural" branded peanut butter that is only natural in the respect that it contains palm oil instead of partially hydrogenated oil. So now you have to watch what you buy because there are two styles of natural peanut butter: really-truly-natural (peanuts and salt) and palm-oil-natural. Unfortunately this stuff is only palm-oil-natural (see also: Jif Natural). It's OK peanut butter, but the name of it intentionally misleads consumers.

Call me crazy, but I don't think every food needs to be sweet. Truly all-natural PB is so versatile and healthy. Sadly most Americans associate PB only with sweet, but there is a world of tasty foods out there that use PB, and there is absolutely zero need for sugar.

My wife bought several jars of this nicely priced Member's Mark peanut butter without looking at the contents. When we went to open one when we ran out of a previous purchase, we noticed the oil had risen to the top. There was a half inch of oil on top. And stirring this NO STIR peanut butter is no picnic. I guess it's been sitting on a warehouse shelf for a number of years already. Best If Used By date is 2 months out, May 25, 2023.

It's great tasting peanut butter but it's covered in oil at the top even though the label clearly says "no stir". No matter how hard you try you still spill some oil on the counter while stirring it. Also by the bottom of the jar it gets dry because there is no way for you to mix all that oil back in evenly.

I love most Member's Mark products, so I decided to try their creamy peanut butter. Wow, it tastes great and is very creamy. However, after scraping my tongue, brushing my tongue with toothpaste and gargling with mouthwash, I could not get rid of the taste on my tongue and in my mouth. I will not buy this peanut butter again.

I returned my recalled jif and grabbed one of these since it was all they had in stock. When I got home I realized two of the ingredients are mono unsaturated fat and poly unsaturated fat which are no good. My wife and i use a lot of peanut butter for our protein shakes before and after the gym and we dont eat garbage. Name brands took those out long ago. Not buying any more of this!

I don't review products but I had to on this one. I have been burned by store brand peanut butter and was so skeptical on trying this. My husband and kids eat a large jar of peanut butter every two weeks, so I was looking for lower cost option since we were going through so much. I picked this up and my husband can't put it down. He says he loves it better than Jif that he used to swear by. I tried it this morning and the taste is phenomenal. I would highly recommend for anyone that is on the fence about purchasing.

The only reason for the low star is that on the label it brags to be "no stir" however everything I use it I find myself having to stir the peanut butter because the oils seep to the top. One time it happened within 30 minutes between two sandwiches. Taste is good and if you don't mind stirring it is a good peanut butter.

Jif was removed from the shelves due to a quality problem that Sam's never notified it's customers about. I purchased this thinking it would be a good substitute. I was wrong. While the taste is OK, the consistency and viscosity sub-par. It separates in the "jar" requiring stirring before use. It becomes almost a liquid and runs off the sides of warm toast. I wonder how it would affect baked goods. This is three time deal for us; first, last and only.