Best peanut butter value

Tasty

Tastes good

Makes my husband nutty

100% Favorite

If you had blindfolded me and ask which one was jif,I don't think I could separate member's mark and JIF. The only notable difference to me, was JIF was slightly creamery and smoother, with rising prices I would select the cheaper one everytime.

the outer wrapping is misleading. The wrapper that holds the 2 jars together says "Made with Sea Salt & Cane Sugar". Since I was in a hurry I just grabbed the jars, but at home I noticed the ingredient list states just "Sugar" not Cane Sugar. Nowhere on the container label does it state "Cane Sugar", so I'm not sure if it's really made with Cane Sugar.

As Sam's continues to replace every name brand product with their Members Mark house brand, Natural Skippy got the boot. I keep trying to like it, but it just failed again (and led me to leave this review). It's gritty and generally lacking in that desirable Skippy flavor I got accustomed to add a kid. I know it won't do any good, but please, please hear my plea and bring back Skippy!

Be sure you realize that the All Natural label doesn't lead you to believe it is old fashioned peanut butter. The best peanut butter has only peanuts and salt. This one has palm oil (not good) and cane sugar (not needed). If you don't care about those ingredients then you will like it.

I eat a lot of peanut butter, I mean a lot. I eat spoonfuls of it every night before bed. I used to eat JIF until I tried this stuff during a shortage of the other stuff. I have never gone back. This is the perfect texture, thickness and flavor. I even tried the Kirkland brand to see how it stacks up and it’s not even close. This is truly no stir compared to most natural peanut butters and has far better taste.