I'm disappointed in this product. To be honest I purchased this for my dog, he loves frozen peanut butter treats and I fill ice cube trays with peanut butter for him. After long walks in the Texas heat he really looks forward to these but this peanut butter is too oily and he will not eat it. Only thing he won't eat, Amazing!

This pb is very peanutty. My only complaint is that it’s a bit too thin. That may be because of the palm oil, but Jif natural isn’t this thin… and uses palm oil. For those who are complaining that it has sugar and palm oil, perhaps you should know that most people don’t like stirring pb, so jif, skippy and members mark all use palm oil so we won’t have to stir. The palm oil is much better than hydrogenated oil that’s in regular peanut butter. The FDA states that it must contain 90% peanuts to be natural and no chemicals. I will buy this again, I just wish it were thicker.

Pleasantly surprised... I'm trying to eat as healthy as I can, trying to choose foods without preservatives etc; as much as I can, and I chose this peanut butter vs jif because this one didn't have all the other stuff that jif creamy pb has... Members Mark Creamy: Roasted Peanuts, Sugar, Palm Oil, Sea Salt....... Jif Creamy: Roasted Peanuts, Sugar, Contains 2% Or Less Of: Molasses, Fully Hydrogenated Vegetable Oils (rapeseed And Soybean), Mono And Diglycerides, Salt

I eat a lot of peanut butter, I mean a lot. I eat spoonfuls of it every night before bed. I used to eat JIF until I tried this stuff during a shortage of the other stuff. I have never gone back. This is the perfect texture, thickness and flavor. I even tried the Kirkland brand to see how it stacks up and it’s not even close. This is truly no stir compared to most natural peanut butters and has far better taste.

Be sure you realize that the All Natural label doesn't lead you to believe it is old fashioned peanut butter. The best peanut butter has only peanuts and salt. This one has palm oil (not good) and cane sugar (not needed). If you don't care about those ingredients then you will like it.

Creamy and tasty! Price is perfect. Only downfall, the label says NO STIR is not true. Lots of oils throughout the jar but if you don’t stir, once you get to the last inch of the jar, the peanut butter is very thick because there is not enough oil. Make sure you stir!

As Sam's continues to replace every name brand product with their Members Mark house brand, Natural Skippy got the boot. I keep trying to like it, but it just failed again (and led me to leave this review). It's gritty and generally lacking in that desirable Skippy flavor I got accustomed to add a kid. I know it won't do any good, but please, please hear my plea and bring back Skippy!

I always use my hand mixer with a single beater to incorporate the oils in the "natural" peanut butter I purchase. After doing that with this version, the viscosity of this stuff ended up in the range of room temperature ketchup. Heck, honey is thicker than tis stuff.

Normally I am strictly a Jif purchaser; however, because of the difference in price, good reviews and the quality of MM products, I elected to try this peanut butter. I want to start by saying this is very good PB. Very creamy and the flavor is rich. I did find that it is not a no stir product as the label says. Over time the oils will come to the top just like any other natural PB. If you don't stir it, the top will be creamy and the bottom will be hard and thick. I found if while you are storing the unopened jars, put them in the cabinet upside down. This allows the oils to permeate back to the bottom of the jar and will make it easir to stir up.

Although this peanut butter taste's good, the oil rises to the top far worse than other brands.