I have bought this item about 5 times. Consistently finding a glob of oil on top when breaking the seal on a new jar. It is marketed as "No Stir" which is not true. The peanut butter itself has great flavor, the peanut butter at the bottom of the jar is very dense and needs some of the oil from the top of the jar. MM brand claims to be as good as the national brand, but you can put MM next to JIF and you will see the difference immediately.

The item title says this "Peanut Butter", which is an FDA-controlled technical name. however the label on the physical object I received says "Peanut Butter Spread", which is **not**. "90% peanuts" is just on the line. Maybe they aren't certain that the manufacturing process can reliably land on the right side of that. Or maybe it's something else?

Good peanut butter. This replaced the Jiff all natural product that was really good! The Members Mark is still good quality and has a good flavor. However the consistency varies a lot. It can range from real oily to thick and pastie. Batches are probably not mixed(stirred) well before canning.

Very little difference if any from Skippy & about $2 less. Also gets better health ratings

Great taste, natural and best of all don't have to stir for a natural peanut butter

I like the taste of this and it is not too salty compared to Skippy.

Good choice for body builders

We are a JIF family, but when the recall occured in May/June 2022 I could not find it anywhere, sooooo i hesitantly bought this thinking it was going to be a pain to deal with. I figured I would have to stir, stir, stir to eat some. I also thought it would be flavorless or at best have only a mild flavor. I WAS HAPPILY WRONG!!! This stuff is great! My family loves it and it's great in recipes. Super find!

I was really weary buying a store brand but I also did not want to make another stop so I took the chance. Peanut butter is a go to snack for me - plain, mixed with honey, on crackers, celery - i could go on but I am sure you get the idea. I did not want something that tasted stale, or that I had to stir because the oil separated (sorry that is just ewww) and I wanted a fresh taste. This gave me all that and at a very competitive price - Will be our family's new regular brand

My mistake in purchasing... I didn’t read the label close enough to learn this is a mixture of oil, sugar and peanuts. When shopping I entered “Peanut Butter” not thinking the choices would include non-peanut butter. This tastes awful and is not the healthy product I thought I had ordered.