After opening both jars there was at least a quarter inch of oil on top. After a lot of stirring it was barely acceptable. We had to stir like this EVERY time we used it. After using half of the first jar we opened the second one to see if it was better. Unfortunately it was the same, threw them both out at that point.

We purchased a two pack and ended up returning the jars. We opened one jar and it seemed ok at first. It was smooth and easy to spread. Unfortunately it was very oily and separated. We tried stirring it a few times, but it was just gross and the texture was terrible.

I have been buying this product for years and was very satisfied until last two purchases. It is now so oily you most definitely do need to stir it. Never had to do that before. Today I opened a new jar, saw I was going to have to stir, and when I turned the jar over in a bowl half just flowed out it was so oily. Peanut butter is not supposed to flow! The first set of two that were like this I just thought were a glitch in the processing. But now I've got two more just the same way. Will not buy again!

This product is not what we expected. I expected it to be smooth and creamy and easily spreadable over sandwich bread. It is not, it's a pretty hard consistency. I found it difficult to use a butter knife to get it out of the jar. Three other friends and family members who have bought this product also has the same problems with it. I would not recommend this product for anything like baking or sandwiches.

I have been satisfied with other Member's Mark Items, so I decided to try this one due to lack of options. The taste is okay, but not great. The no stir claim is NOT TRUE. You have to stir and stir and even then it's still greasy. Get to the bottom of the jar and it's so hard it won't spread. First and last purchase of this item.

The peanut butter is a little dry, I’ll go back to Jif and pay the extra money.

The best peanut butter ever. Better than Jif.

another members mark item i am very impressed with---will purchase again

This PB is not natural, it has added palm oil.

Broken jar in the box due to very poor packing