If you like Jiff and Peter Pan, you'll like this too. The ingredient list seems nearly identical to them as well. Natural? Not sure why it gets that label.

I really like it better than any I’ve had. I’m a Diabetic and it work’s good for me but my system is very picky so it may not work better for you. I’ve been eating it for over a year at least it don’t spike my sugar as bad.

Product oily on top, then to stiff on the bottom of the jar. I made my usual peanut butter cookies and they came out hard as a rock had to break with pliers to use as dog treats. Very disappointed.

I had to put the peanut butter in the refrigerator just so it wouldn't be runny. Texture is all wrong. This is not real peanut butter, that's why they call it "Peanut butter Spread"

Before 2023 the taste was creamy and bold. But they must have changed vendors and the taste is not the same. It used to taste like Skippy natural, now it tastes like JIF.

I originally bought this because of the affordable price. This has to be the very best I've ever purchased. I got more than I expected with the awesome taste and incredible price. Thank you Members Mark for another incredible, awesome product.

It was another famous peanut butter I was after and bought Members Mark instead. Natural, no stir and no hydrogenated oil. It’s cheaper and more important, it tastes better! Try It!

This would truly be “all natural” if it didn’t have the added sugar. Truly “all natural” is just peanuts. Unfortunately we have to go to Sams competitor to get a real “all natural” peanut butter which also happens to be organic too.

Delicious flavor, so I was sad about this peanut butter. So disappointing, that the “No Stir” peanut butter just wasn’t true. There was a big layer of oil on top, and you just had to stir it.

I am very picky on peanut butter consistency and how well it holds up in little containers when food prepping. I LOVE this peanut butter. It is smooth, not oily, and has a wonderful peanut butter taste that doesn't taste fake like some out there.