I am not a huge peanut butter fan and am particular about what peanut butter we use. This is hands down the best tasting peanut butter for way less money than the other brands. We absolutely love the creaminess and it has such great flavor too!

I'm not sure if they changed the product since certain other reviewers mentioned it was oily, but mine was not oily at all. It has a good amount of salty flavor like Smucker's Natural - and the price is awesome for how much you get. Worth it!

My family has been Peter Pan lovers forever. This has now replaced it! Tastes the same and doesn't have ingredients that you can't pronounce, not to mention it's cheaper! We love Member's Mark!!

It was another famous peanut butter I was after and bought Members Mark instead. Natural, no stir and no hydrogenated oil. It’s cheaper and more important, it tastes better! Try It!

This peanut butter has great taste and it's smooth. However, I'm not a fan of the added sugar and palm oil, but if I run out of my regular PB, this is my top substitute!

I am very picky on peanut butter consistency and how well it holds up in little containers when food prepping. I LOVE this peanut butter. It is smooth, not oily, and has a wonderful peanut butter taste that doesn't taste fake like some out there.

By far my favorite in flavor and in price. I absolutely cannot stand JIF or Skippy (any of those) I can taste other ingredients overpowering the peanuts. Love that the peanut flavor is so strong and you don't have to stir it much.

Lots of oil, you will definately need to stir this peanutbutter... over and over and over. Overall a good taste, but I cant get past having to stir the peanutbutter every use for the first 2/3s of the jar.

I bought this when my usual peanut butter brand was recalled. The Members Mark brand is the absolute best in taste and consistency. Will never go back to my old brand!

Delicious flavor, so I was sad about this peanut butter. So disappointing, that the “No Stir” peanut butter just wasn’t true. There was a big layer of oil on top, and you just had to stir it.