Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, 40 oz., 2 pk. for
Member's Mark Natural Creamy Peanut Butter, 40 oz., 2 pk.
4.7 out of 5 stars
stars8,055 ratings2,278 reviews
  1. 5 stars84% (6,754)
  2. 4 stars9% (756)
  3. 3 stars3% (247)
  4. 2 stars1% (99)
  5. 1 star2% (199)

Member photos

  • +26 images
Sort by |
Showing 2,051-2,060 of 2,278 reviews
Feb 5, 2024
Katie
2 out of 5 stars review

Thin and runny

I don't know why but when the lockdowns happened with covid, they changed the recipe of this peanut butter or something. It's really runny now. Would probably be good for cooking sauces with but for pb&j /sandwiches it's terrible now. Taste is good but texture sucks.

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579
Jul 24, 2021
Hobbychef55
3 out of 5 stars review

WOW!

This is the best pb I've ever had. The taste is phenomenal! Love that it spreads so easily without tearing bread. It has to be stirred periodically but no big deal. We also love it because it's so much easier to get our dog to take her pills. It doesn't stick to one's mouth like other brands. Again, the flavor is fantastic!!

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579
Oct 11, 2022
BigEdSr
5 out of 5 stars review

Great product...

I got this to make cookies, since my regular brand was on recall. I was very surprised to find the taste was equal to my old brand, and it worked equally well in my wife's cookie dough. The grandkids loved it on sandwiches, and said it was better than the name brand.

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579
Oct 21, 2021
kathys999
4 out of 5 stars review

Taste great, not sure why they call it NATURAL

I didn't read the ingredients on this peanut butter before I bought it, thought NATURAL would mean it didn't have any added sugar - I was wrong. It doesn't contain hydrogenated oils, simply peanuts, sugar, palm oil and sea salt. (sea salt impresses people as if it doesn't have the same effects as regular salt - nutritional-wise, just minus iodine. Its a trend that sells.) As far as the taste - its really good, taste like jif to me, I did a side by side taste test. The Sams Peanut Butter is thicker and not as creamy. I would buy it again, price is much better than name brands. Jars are 40 ounces vs 48 oz on the other name brands but still computes to less per ounce . .10 cents VS 07 cents.

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579
Jul 12, 2023
Tort156
3 out of 5 stars review

Not Natural

This is not a natural peanut butter. This contains added sugar and oil. I bought it in a hurry, not realizing it's not actually natural. Natural peanut butter is meant to NOT contain added sugar and oils and sometimes even salt. It is very misleading and shouldn't be allowed to be labeled natural.

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579
Jun 15, 2020
KCU
2 out of 5 stars review

It's just not good

I read the ingredients and realized it wasn't a true natural PB before buying. I still gave it a whirl based on the low price for sandwiches and whatnot. It's just not good. Weird taste, gritty, not peanut buttery. If I'm going to eat not actual natural PB, I'll just stick with Jif from now on.

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579
Jun 23, 2021
Mari
4 out of 5 stars review

Smooth And Creamy

We always bought Wegmans or Safeway’s store brands, but those have been hard to find so we tried this. This is a really good substitute and my husband and son like it a lot. I like it, but my pet conure really loves it. This is our new go to brand. Bird and husband approved!

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579
May 17, 2025
WinterPark Toni
5 out of 5 stars review

Awesome

This is the best peanut butter I have ever eaten. There's no heartburn there's no extra added sugar there's no extra salt it is creamy and delicious and you don't have to stir it. I absolutely love it I think you will too. I definitely recommend it it's way better with natural ingredients compared to some of those name brands.

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579
Jan 27, 2019
DNTS
5 out of 5 stars review

Great taste and great price!

I didn't realize this was "natural" until I opened it and saw oil sitting on top. I don't buy the natural in any brand because don't like having to stir it before each use. I had nothing to lose because of the money back guarantee so I got out a heavier serving spoon and mixed it thoroughly - including the hard stuff at the bottom. I was surprised that I didn't have to mix it again - not even a little bit. It also tastes great!

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579
Sep 12, 2018
Nuts
3 out of 5 stars review

Spread????

The difference between peanut butter and peanut butter spread..... peanut butter needs to be 90 percent peanuts and peanut butter SPREAD only needs to be only 60 percent peanuts. What else do they put in it? Palm oil and they say CANE SUGAR.... they act like it's something special..... IT'S SUGAR .....why do they need to put sugar in peanut butter at all????? DON'T EVER BUY PEANUT BUTTER SPREAD

Helpful?4J8UA77KAVJO7874219579