My wife bought several jars of this nicely priced Member's Mark peanut butter without looking at the contents. When we went to open one when we ran out of a previous purchase, we noticed the oil had risen to the top. There was a half inch of oil on top. And stirring this NO STIR peanut butter is no picnic. I guess it's been sitting on a warehouse shelf for a number of years already. Best If Used By date is 2 months out, May 25, 2023.

From the time I purchased and opened up this peanut butter the “No Stir” is a lie. First time opening the oil was all in top and spilled. Every time I open it has to be stirred. I should have returned it. I am going to donate since I hate dealing with stirring.

I use a hand mixer to blend/incorporate the oils that all "natural" peanut butters have on the surface. After doing so with this brand, this stuff is literally pourable at room temperature. I've never seen this in the numerous "natural" peanut butters I've purchased over the years. It's only redeeming quality is the taste but I won't be purchasing this stuff again due to its room temperature ketchup like viscosity.

My husband is Mr. Peanut Butter - an *authority." He declares this to be the BEST. AND - it's natural but not all separated and oily and yucky. Doubts you'll find better at such a good price. (Our doggo loves it as well, and she's a picky lil' brat.)

Tastes good, but quite runny. It ran out of my kid's PB&J. Not a mess I want to deal with every day with a three year old. However, it's perfect for dipping (i.e. apple slices, pretzel rods) and drizzling. True to its name, it does not require stirring.

The label on the jar says, “natural- no stir” but it MUST be stirred and it is messy to try to incorporate the oil on top into the peanut butter at the bottom of the jar, which causes it to be dry and lumpy. Although I have bought this brand for a couple of years, I think I will return to Jiff

This is the best pb I've ever had. The taste is phenomenal! Love that it spreads so easily without tearing bread. It has to be stirred periodically but no big deal. We also love it because it's so much easier to get our dog to take her pills. It doesn't stick to one's mouth like other brands. Again, the flavor is fantastic!!

We loved this peanut butter because it was delicious, such a good price and had simple ingredients (peanuts and salt). Now, it contains sugar and palm oil which not only drastically changed the texture but also the taste and nutritional value. Boo, Sam's Club. Boo.

I love most Member's Mark products, so I decided to try their creamy peanut butter. Wow, it tastes great and is very creamy. However, after scraping my tongue, brushing my tongue with toothpaste and gargling with mouthwash, I could not get rid of the taste on my tongue and in my mouth. I will not buy this peanut butter again.

This is a good peanut butter if you like peanut butters like Jif. Personally, I usually buy sugar free peanut butter but Sams Club doesn't sell sugar free peanut butter unfortunately. I am not sure what other reviewers were talking about but it is not thin. It has the texture of a no stir peanut butter like Jif, Skippy, Reese and all the other ones. I don't think I will be purchasing this again because it is not sugar free.