Better than I expected but it does separate! It says it doesn't separate like other natural brands but not true! But if you don't mind the separating, you will be happy with the peanut butter.

This is great peanut butter and it has less ingredients than JIF or other brands and it's cheaper. I will continue buying this. My family also loves the Members Mark Strawberry Preserves

All I get to do with this peanut butter is stir it. Drug myself through the first jar to open the second jar and find the oil all at the top. Won’t even begin to use the second jar. Going back to JIF.

Great value, price per ounce, 2 table spoons on bread, Fold over,( 3 slices ) 1 vanilla premier protein drink , Bite with sip, thats a meal replacement

Call me crazy, but I don't think every food needs to be sweet. Truly all-natural PB is so versatile and healthy. Sadly most Americans associate PB only with sweet, but there is a world of tasty foods out there that use PB, and there is absolutely zero need for sugar.

It used to be that "natural peanut butter" contained only peanuts, and maybe salt. During the anti-transfat craze a few years ago, many companies started selling "natural" branded peanut butter that is only natural in the respect that it contains palm oil instead of partially hydrogenated oil. So now you have to watch what you buy because there are two styles of natural peanut butter: really-truly-natural (peanuts and salt) and palm-oil-natural. Unfortunately this stuff is only palm-oil-natural (see also: Jif Natural). It's OK peanut butter, but the name of it intentionally misleads consumers.

I don't review products but I had to on this one. I have been burned by store brand peanut butter and was so skeptical on trying this. My husband and kids eat a large jar of peanut butter every two weeks, so I was looking for lower cost option since we were going through so much. I picked this up and my husband can't put it down. He says he loves it better than Jif that he used to swear by. I tried it this morning and the taste is phenomenal. I would highly recommend for anyone that is on the fence about purchasing.

As a life-long Jif devotee, I'll admit I was skeptical of a "generic" peanut butter. This Members Mark PB is better than Jif and the price can't be beat. The flavor is great, not too sugary and just the right balance of salt and creaminess. This is our go-to brand of PB now and I have no reason to go back to Jif. Thanks Sam's Club!

It's great tasting peanut butter but it's covered in oil at the top even though the label clearly says "no stir". No matter how hard you try you still spill some oil on the counter while stirring it. Also by the bottom of the jar it gets dry because there is no way for you to mix all that oil back in evenly.

Jif was removed from the shelves due to a quality problem that Sam's never notified it's customers about. I purchased this thinking it would be a good substitute. I was wrong. While the taste is OK, the consistency and viscosity sub-par. It separates in the "jar" requiring stirring before use. It becomes almost a liquid and runs off the sides of warm toast. I wonder how it would affect baked goods. This is three time deal for us; first, last and only.