Since the Loveland store stopped carrying the 6# Peter Pan I thought I'd try this. I purchased about 5 or 6 of these and the consistency was anywhere from nice and firm to where it would actually run off the spoon to where it actually had about 1/2 a cup of oil on the top and was very runny. It was about 50% of the time that it was runny and oily. Wish they'd bring back the Peter Pan, like they did once before.

the outer wrapping is misleading. The wrapper that holds the 2 jars together says "Made with Sea Salt & Cane Sugar". Since I was in a hurry I just grabbed the jars, but at home I noticed the ingredient list states just "Sugar" not Cane Sugar. Nowhere on the container label does it state "Cane Sugar", so I'm not sure if it's really made with Cane Sugar.

My family has been eating this peanut butter for years. The ONLY reason I don't give it 5 stars is because it says on the jar "no stir", but I do indeed have to stir it before using it, the oil does separate and stays on top. It's a great value though and tastes delicious.

One of my favorite comfort foods is peanut butter on toast, and this hits the spot! Really smooth and creamy with no separation. I bought it because the other brands have hydrogenated vegetable oil. There are no organic brands that I like, so this is the next best thing. I was wary because I was afraid it would taste off compared to name brands, but it is just as good or better. I highly recommend it.

For those of you who say this is just as good as JIF, you must not be eating the same JIF that I do. It's not even close, at all, period. Also a hint: if it says "no stir" on the label, you're gonna have to stir it. I don't even know how Sam's gets away with that. Tolerable, at best.

Be sure you realize that the All Natural label doesn't lead you to believe it is old fashioned peanut butter. The best peanut butter has only peanuts and salt. This one has palm oil (not good) and cane sugar (not needed). If you don't care about those ingredients then you will like it.

The only peanut butter we buy - natural and truly no stir! It’s creamy and it’s a great value.

This PB is not natural, it has added palm oil.

The only peanut butter that I eat. Great for diabetics and people on keto

Not 100% peanuts- has oil & sugar thought it was more natural- should have read label closer