I have eaten this peanut butter for years now. Nutritionally, I'm not sure how it compares to other well known brands, but the taste is great, it is smooth, and the price is hard to beat. I also bake with it. I can't tell the difference between this and other name brands.

Love this peanut butter. We have only eaten Skippy Natural for at least a decade now. This is slightly smoother and ever so slightly sweeter??? Unlike the skippy natural, you really do not need to stir it AT ALL!!! My husband appreciates that. Fabulous, fresh roasted peanut taste and a wonderful substitute for skippy natural that saves us a few dollars in our large household. Have you seen the JIF to-go peanut butter cups? Buy some 2 oz cups with lids and fill with this for work or travel! Member’s Mark, you hit this one out of the ballpark!

love this peanut butter, but can not find it stocked in the clubs had to order online. I find that the online inventory to be inaccurate, Says not in stock for shipping and not available for pickup, but when i go to the club it is in stock. Also, I am a plus member and when I order cat food there is a shipping charge added on to the cost What's up?

This has quickly become my new favorite peanut butter. Yes, it does separate the oil on top, but when they say "No Stir" they mean it because the oil collection is very minimal and I think it actually helps with both the flavor and texture. I will be buying this again and again.

I’v bought this peanut butter for years, it was great until this time. I noticed it was now no stir, didn’t read the label, I bought it. Didn’t know “THEY ADDED SUGAR” and it’s really sweet. Never again!! I wanted peanut butter, not peanut sugar butter🥲

My husband loves peanut butter! The last 4-5 years we have switched from the name brand, peanut butter to members mark natural for many reasons. 1st taste, calories, fat & sugar content. The price for 2 isn’t bad either. I make sure we never run low much less out!

I have been enjoying peanut butter for 70 years and usually ate the healthier choices in brands. This peanut butter matches the fat, carb and sodium content of the “healthy brand” but is the best tasting peanut butter I have ever tasted. I bought two for my daughter who at first was annoyed that they were so large and there were two of them. She has limited storage. After 3 months she is on her 4th jar and my granddaughter loves it so much she eats it by the spoonful for snacks. Please never discontinue this product. My husband made me buy 6 in reserve because he is afraid Sams would run out or discontinue it!

After cheating on this peanut butter and trying other brands, I had to come back. The consistency, flavor, and richness was hard to beat. Having an extra tub in the pantry is also convenient. But paired with honeycrisp apples or a slightly underripe banana is my favorite way to eat this peanut butter!

If all things equal my favorite PB is Smart Balance but it's so close and MM is such a better value it's the way I roll. Perfect no stir sets on my counter all the time delicious. The only negative is it has Palm oil and SB is strictly cane sugar. This is the only reason I took away star.

The Member's Mark Natural Creamy Peanut Butter is just as good as other name-brand ones, but at almost half the price. It is very creamy, tastes great, and made only from natural ingredients. I bought this 2-pack just a little over what I have been paying for a single jar of JIF.