I usually don’t buy store brand anything but decided to give this a try. First it’s absolutely delicious, second it has very few ingredients. I was sincerely surprised. So I just have to say kudos.

I am very disappointed with this peanut butter because it says on the label "NO STIR" which to me means I don't have to stir it. But I di have to stir it. I want to know if I can return this product.

I wouldn't say this is the best peanut butter ever BUT it is pretty darn good and for what you pay it's an amazing value. This will last us awhile but we'll definitely be restocking once we're out.

I didn't realize how much I love this stuff until I went to pick up our families weekly pack and found them to be out of stock LOL. Even with Jiff being on a small sale this week, it's more expensive than MM at it's regular price :(

There is nothing natural about this peanut butter. It is the same ingredients as all the others except it tries to make you think it's different by putting "Natural" on the front! Tastes fine, just like all the other oil and sugar added butters.

Before 2023 the taste was creamy and bold. But they must have changed vendors and the taste is not the same. It used to taste like Skippy natural, now it tastes like JIF.

My family has been Peter Pan lovers forever. This has now replaced it! Tastes the same and doesn't have ingredients that you can't pronounce, not to mention it's cheaper! We love Member's Mark!!

Delicious flavor, so I was sad about this peanut butter. So disappointing, that the “No Stir” peanut butter just wasn’t true. There was a big layer of oil on top, and you just had to stir it.

Made with real sugar. Smooth and creamy. Pretty healthy compared to other peanut butter. I grab a spoonful when I'm craving a snack. Good fats and protein to help keep those hunger pains away and only 200 calories.

Lots of oil, you will definately need to stir this peanutbutter... over and over and over. Overall a good taste, but I cant get past having to stir the peanutbutter every use for the first 2/3s of the jar.