I have bought this several times and haven't experienced the oily separation others have even after sitting for weeks before being used. Will buy again.

I had never tried this peanut butter before. I was pleasantly surprised with taste and texture! This has become my spread of choice! Highly recommend!!

This is normal peanut butter. It's not organic, it's not all natural, it's not JIF. It tastes good, but it separates, which is annoying. I bought it when JIF wasn't available. If that happens again, I would buy this again.

Tastes great, value is excellent, container last forever even if eaten everyday, kids love it just as much as me. Initially bought because the brand names were sold out, now there’s no going back. Superb.

This is my 2nd time ordering this PB, it is now my all-time favorite. We have used Jif for most of my life. This is not as sugary as Jif brand; it is just right. Maybe they will bring out a chunky style PB.

This is not an “all natural” peanut butter. It contains just as much sugar as a National brand, and it contains palm shortening. It has a good flavor, but the labeling is a bit misleading.

I am not a huge peanut butter fan and am particular about what peanut butter we use. This is hands down the best tasting peanut butter for way less money than the other brands. We absolutely love the creaminess and it has such great flavor too!

Love this peanut butter. It's on the oily side, so you do have to stir it, but that's exactly how I like it, and why I prefer this Member's Mark brand. Good stuff!

I didn't realize how much I love this stuff until I went to pick up our families weekly pack and found them to be out of stock LOL. Even with Jiff being on a small sale this week, it's more expensive than MM at it's regular price :(

I'm not sure if they changed the product since certain other reviewers mentioned it was oily, but mine was not oily at all. It has a good amount of salty flavor like Smucker's Natural - and the price is awesome for how much you get. Worth it!