Only because it has OTHER ingredients besides peanuts, same as Regular old peanut butter Spread, is it "NO STIR"

No Packing in box and came all busted. My god what a mess !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I like that it's creamy but don't like that there is added sugar and palm oil, it's too sweet for my palate and the palm oil is unnecessary.

The taste of this peanut butter is just as good as the name brand, but the oil does seperate and requires occasional stiring

Very oily, almost soupy and needs to be stirred. Just get a name brand peanut butter because members mark has not come close.

I bought this when my usual peanut butter brand was recalled. The Members Mark brand is the absolute best in taste and consistency. Will never go back to my old brand!

Prior to the recall, we used Jif natural peanut butter exclusively. This has a bit more sodium, 115 vs. 80 grams per serving, but tastes almost identical. I'm very happy with this product and may just continue buying it.

I usually don’t buy store brand anything but decided to give this a try. First it’s absolutely delicious, second it has very few ingredients. I was sincerely surprised. So I just have to say kudos.

I wondered how this is "No Stir". But then I found the ingredients (printed in a tiny typeface), and two culprits emerged, Palm Oil and sugar. I’m going to return it and get some PB that I have to stir, like Smucker's…

I am not a huge peanut butter fan and am particular about what peanut butter we use. This is hands down the best tasting peanut butter for way less money than the other brands. We absolutely love the creaminess and it has such great flavor too!