This peanut butter taste very good and is comparable with similar natural brands. If you're used to buying the others, as I am, you expect to have to stir a little to mix the oil back in. So it's not unusually oily. The price is a very good value. I will certainly continue to purchase this product.

This is natural peanut butter and as such has oil on the surface, which can be stirred back in easily. Taste is good. However, I usually buy Jif natural and I will probably go back to it as the sodium for the Jif product is lower. I do wish Sam's offered more low sodium products.

Love this peanut butter! Best part is it is not made with soy oil! Companies will do anything to save money! Including not using peanut oil in PEANUT butter. However, this peanut is authentic and true to it's creamy label. My advice: still stir! Unless you want a dryer content when you reach the bottom of the jar.

This is the 2nd time I have purchased this Peanut Butter and we absolutely love it❣️ To us this taste just as good as Jif and we have eaten Jif all of our lives. This is now the only peanut butter we want to eat. Never have to stir and is very creamy!

Value for money. Huge jars. Like everything about the USA. Bigger & better. Now all we need is an overhaul of our churches, so the parish priests don't expect a guaranteed income while bludgeoning our hopes and dreams in prayer life while they consider their jobs a 9 to 5 situation.

This has quickly become my new favorite peanut butter. Yes, it does separate the oil on top, but when they say "No Stir" they mean it because the oil collection is very minimal and I think it actually helps with both the flavor and texture. I will be buying this again and again.

I have eaten this peanut butter for years now. Nutritionally, I'm not sure how it compares to other well known brands, but the taste is great, it is smooth, and the price is hard to beat. I also bake with it. I can't tell the difference between this and other name brands.

I'd pretty much given up on peanut butter years ago as the oil used in them changed and gave me heart burn issues. But something told me to try out this one and boy am I glad I did as this is the best tasting peanut butter that I've had since I was a child! I love to dip apple slices into a couple of tablespoons full and also just eat it off the spoon and I'm not a peanut butter person! I'm on my 2nd double jar purchase and hope no one decides to mess with the recipe as I can't get enough of it!

My husband loves peanut butter! The last 4-5 years we have switched from the name brand, peanut butter to members mark natural for many reasons. 1st taste, calories, fat & sugar content. The price for 2 isn’t bad either. I make sure we never run low much less out!

Great product! I always have this on hand. I mix it with Sam's honey and Sam's Almond butter. I keep it on my table to eat on Ezekiel bread toast or spoonfuls by itself. A great source of protein for every meal, and I feel better with the protein. We highly recommend these products!