I've been buying this peanut butter for several years, over the past few months they've changed the formula and it's horrible

I have purchased this peanut butter several times however I was very dissatisfied with the last jar that I opened because it did require stirring. There was at least a half an inch of oil that settled at the top of the jar.

I'm with Dolores-Huge Jars. Great Value. Now I'm going to jump into something completely unrelated and serious---snowmen shouldn't melt in the warm weather. We must call for reform! The snowmen can not because they melted.

Can't say enough about this amazing peanut butter! We love it...creamy, full of flavor and NO high fructose corn syrup! Just simply wonderful ingredients.

I usually don’t buy store brand anything but decided to give this a try. First it’s absolutely delicious, second it has very few ingredients. I was sincerely surprised. So I just have to say kudos.

I love this peanut butter! It is really delicious and creamy. I was reallu surprised with how good it tastes. There was no oil spilling out of my jar like someone else said.

I had to put the peanut butter in the refrigerator just so it wouldn't be runny. Texture is all wrong. This is not real peanut butter, that's why they call it "Peanut butter Spread"

I wouldn't say this is the best peanut butter ever BUT it is pretty darn good and for what you pay it's an amazing value. This will last us awhile but we'll definitely be restocking once we're out.

I am very disappointed with this peanut butter because it says on the label "NO STIR" which to me means I don't have to stir it. But I di have to stir it. I want to know if I can return this product.

I bought this when my usual peanut butter brand was recalled. The Members Mark brand is the absolute best in taste and consistency. Will never go back to my old brand!