These use to be so good, would rate them 5 stars. I'm not sure if they recently changed the formula, now it tastes sour and smells off.

Worst tasting flavor I’ve ever had. I’ve tried tons of protein flavors and brands and this is possibly the worst. They ended up in the trash.

These protein shakes got chunky within a couple of months of purchase, long before the expiration date.

Some of the best protein shakes I've ever tried. And at a great price, cheaper than Premier %26 other brands. Definitely buying more. Make these in more flavors please!

I had such high hopes for these since we are big fans of fair life. awful after taste due to sucralose AND stevia. very thin consistency compared to fair life as well. will be returning!

Soooo very good! I am picky about protein shakes and this one is so delicious. The vanilla is just as good. It tastes like vanilla ice cream. I am so happy to find shakes that you can enjoy drinking.

I've never met a protein shake with better flavor, texture, and overall enjoyment. It's basically strawberry nesquick for adults, except my picky kids love it too! I love that it doesn't have any added color. Such a great product.

I'm a fan of the chocolate and vanilla Members Mark shakes. The strawberry flavor, however, is reminiscent of medicine and it leaves a weird aftertaste. Not very enjoyable on its own, but good for mixing into things.

Sam's Club, please keep these forever! The best protein shake out there! No chalky texture, and delicious taste. I love the strawberry flavor, but the vanilla is also good.

I looked forwards to trying this one because the vanilla flavor is absolutely delicious. Unfortunately, this one not so much. They need to work on the flavor. With a blindfold on I would not have known I was drinking strawberry.