This is a “generic” review for Sam's Club Bakery half sheet cakes: I really like this cake. We purchase a cakes regularly to celebrate monthly birthdays and are never disappointed. The cakes are moist, flavorful, and beautifully decorated. Both icing options are good, though we prefer the whipped icing, as it is a bit less sweet. This is a great cake and you can't beat the price!

it was moist and the decorations were nice, but they forgot to add flavor! They've changed something. Their cakes used to be so good!