Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Cheeseburger Sliders, Frozen, 2.3 oz., 16 ct. for
Member's Mark Cheeseburger Sliders, Frozen, 2.3 oz., 16 ct.
Sort by |
Showing 111-120 of 240 reviews
May 1, 2026
anonymous
1 out of 5 stars review

Misleading description, onions not mentioned.

I know it says in the ingredients list that the patty has onion in it, but I'm unimpressed that it isn't mentioned on the front of the box. It just says "beef patty." Can someone enlighten me as to which part of the cow is the onion?

Helpful?4XCG6EO7FJQX18145308792
Apr 15, 2026
anonymous
2 out of 5 stars review

Hard buns

The bottom bun was rock solid on some of the burgers after they were cooked. There also wasn’t enough cheese on the burgers. I had high hopes for these because my kids love the White Castle burgers but they just weren’t great.

Helpful?4XCG6EO7FJQX18145308792
May 6, 2026
Foody
3 out of 5 stars review

Quick snack

These sliders are not as good as White Castle in my opinion. I may have over microwaved them to make sure the meat is fully cooked but the bread got chewy quick.

Helpful?4XCG6EO7FJQX18145308792
Jan 28, 2026
Michael
2 out of 5 stars review

Poor Substitute For White Castle

Sam's Club carried White Castle cheeseburgers. Then then put out their own and stopped carrying White Castle. So I tried them. Blech! Bland with too much bread. If you want a hunk of heavy bread with a hint of beef and cheese, these are for you. If you want to taste the beef and cheese and have some flavor, these are terrible. They don't even have onions. These need a lot of additions to be decent, which defeats the purpose of convenience frozen packets. Even adding tomatoes pickles and sauce these were still blah. White castle is tasty as it comes out of the packet. Again and again Sam's Club replaces things I like with inferior products that are from a different company, or their own brand. I am running out of reasons to keep a membership.

Helpful?4XCG6EO7FJQX18145308792
Jan 19, 2026
Tamara
2 out of 5 stars review

Cheap tasting %26 pricey for what they are

The positive reviews must be paid for or they have never had whitecastle. And have never made a burger with quality cheese and ground beef. *The meat is too thick %26 taste boiled **The cheese taste cheap. Bun was ok. Now White castle is cheap in a good/naughty way. My daughter didn't like these for her junky food night. But there was no white castle... Waste of my money.. I now will be making full size wagyu burgers on pretzel buns instead.

Helpful?4XCG6EO7FJQX18145308792
Feb 23, 2026
VERONICA
1 out of 5 stars review

Don't waste your money

If I could give zero stars I would. I'm shocked at all the positive reviews. These were worse than burgers i remember from school. Both my kids refused to eat them. I took one bite and understood why. I gave a few to my sister in law for her kids to try. I can't wait to hear back.

Helpful?4XCG6EO7FJQX18145308792
Jan 20, 2026
RDP
1 out of 5 stars review

Not good at all!

I really didn't like these. Usually, I won't go to the trouble to return a food item. Just make a note to not buy it again. But these were so bad I made an exception and returned them to the club. The patties were like a piece of rubber that had a strong onion and garlic flavor. Cheese was tasteless and buns fair at best. I have tasted this meat in a larger frozen burger at one time in the past and it was just as bad then. I recommend that you save your money and time.

Helpful?4XCG6EO7FJQX18145308792
Feb 27, 2026
TRACEY
5 out of 5 stars review

these little sliders were great. perfect snack. For the reviewers saying the bun got tough , you clearly over cooked the product. Wrapped mine in a paper towel and heated in the microwave for the exact time the package stated and they were perfect. i added a bit of mustard and that was it. kinda reminded me of the school cafeteria hamburgers from back in the day. I think the price is good as well.

Helpful?4XCG6EO7FJQX18145308792
Jan 29, 2026
Frank
3 out of 5 stars review

Good but not great.

I think they were pretty good. Maybe a little too heavy on the bread ratio but the flavor was good. I think they microwave better after thawing and cutting back on the cook time. I noticed on the reviews people either love them or hate them. Not quite as good as White Castle but are a better value in my opinion.

Helpful?4XCG6EO7FJQX18145308792
Jan 30, 2026
NottheGrayMan
1 out of 5 stars review

In A Word: No. Try a Cardboard Sandwich Instead.

We are fans of WhiteCastle so we bought these when Sam's stopped carrying them and these Sam's brand were the default option. Our assessment is: - The buns are hard and basically taste like paper - We add a little ketchup and it didn't stay on the bun or meat; just ran off and made a mess with each bite. Weird. - There really was no taste. Not a bad taste, just no taste. It was strange. - Very little cheese. The only way I knew it had cheese was it said so on the box. - Yes, the hamburger meat was a tad thicker, but it had no taste either. So the recommendation is: Try harder, or bring back WhiteCastle, please!

Helpful?4XCG6EO7FJQX18145308792