You can’t tell from the product photos, but these actually are a transparent tinted jelly looking product. Kinda cool if you ask me. The color is subtle and goes on light and can be layered with a gloss. The lip tint by itself is not sticky or overly shiny. I actually love them because I like more subtle color.

I really like these. I have really pale lips. So, it's nice to just put one of these on for moisture and some color instead of lipstick all of the time.

I love these! I got some for me and my daughter. The color is very apparent on my lips but its not like lipstick. It's more like it changes the color of my faded lips to a naturally youthful color, but each one is slightly different. The only thing I don't like is one tube from each pack I bought doesn't work, but the colors themselves are great.

Not worth the money. I’ve had ph balms before and these don’t work like the other ones. I don’t notice any difference in the plum vs the nude colors. The second time using it, one of the balms broke. I cant believe these cost about $5 each! Don’t buy.

total waste of money. don't buy

These are terrible, no color and not even a good balm.

I tried all four. None of them left any color on my lips. They did leave my lips sticky though