I've been buying the Atkins shakes for years, usually the dark chocolate and the milk if they are out of stock. For some reason SAM'S has not had the dark chocolate for quite a while. I saw the milk chocolate but in a different color red box and noticed that is has more protein and was on sale. I thought I'd try it and bought 3 boxes. BIG MISTAKE! They taste terrible, nothing like the milk chocolate. It also has a terrible after taste. Please bring back the old shakes. Also you can't return these. so alot of money gone to waste.

The Atkins 30 grams protein milk chocolate shake is too sweet. I wanted the Atkins Coffee Shake but Sams was out of them so I bought this Milk Chocolate 30 grams protein shake instead. I hope my husband will drink them. I will not be buying this again.

The Atkins high protein milkshake is chalky tasting and leaves an aftertaste just like every other product and brand out there. So unfortunate as their original milk chocolate with a lower protein was creamy, smooth and delicious. hope Sam's Club brings back the original milk chocolate

Great flavor

First and last time purchasing this product. Brought it home, stuck it in the refrigerator over night. The expiration shows 06/09/26 and the furst one i pulled out was solid like pudding, very disgusting and nasty. The second one was liquid as it shiuld have been. I wont chance this product again for the price of one case.

Great taste and high protein.

These are good for chocolate. The colder the better! Also has probiotics in it.

Taste great,very filling, price is great

Atkins tastes good and fills me up.

My husband's morning drink