Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Member ratings & reviews for
Member's Mark 12" Pumpkin Pie (60 oz., 1 ct.)
2.9 out of 5 stars
stars20 ratings17 reviews
  1. 5 stars40% (8)
  2. 4 stars0% (0)
  3. 3 stars10% (2)
  4. 2 stars10% (2)
  5. 1 star40% (8)
Sort by |
Showing 1-10 of 17 reviews
Nov 29, 2011
MaryNFSM
5 out of 5 stars review

Very Good!

After tasting this at the Sams Club, my sisters (from out-of-town) and I said this is a very good pumpkin pie--not too sweet, enough spices, really good texture. We are sweet potato pie eaters. I purchased 2---one to eat now and the other I froze. Will purchase again.

Helpful?3U5EFX6MXV5T16262155253
Nov 16, 2011
JanInTheNCMountains
5 out of 5 stars review

I'll be back for more!

Wow! this is great pumpkin pie! No need to make Aunt Dot's family recipe anymore when I can buy pumpkin pie that tastes this good.

Helpful?3U5EFX6MXV5T16262155253
Nov 26, 2014
cookiemaven
5 out of 5 stars review

excellent tasting pie

Excellent pumpkin pie that my family prefers to those from other bakeries in our area. Good value, too.

Helpful?3U5EFX6MXV5T16262155253
Oct 19, 2016
Piepiemeohmy
5 out of 5 stars review

Perfect pumpkin pie

I have had pumpkin pie from every restaurant and grocery store in the area and none have been this good. You may say i am a pumpkin pie expert lol. I usually but 6 or 7 a year from sams. Thanks keep up the great work

Helpful?3U5EFX6MXV5T16262155253
Oct 6, 2018
oceaneco1
2 out of 5 stars review

Sam's Changed the Recipe on the Pumpkin Pie!

They changed the recipe and it has a gummy texture now. It is not good and we will no longer buy our pies from Sam's Club. Yuck!!!

Helpful?3U5EFX6MXV5T16262155253
Nov 11, 2018
ColoradoJo
1 out of 5 stars review

this pie is not edible

I bought Sam'sClub pies several years ago and they were decent. It I bought this pumpkin pie yesterday and it is horrible. It is funny and the flavor is horrible. No one was able to finish their piece. I will never buy a pumpkin pie from Sam's again. Don't waste your money.

Helpful?3U5EFX6MXV5T16262155253
Oct 31, 2018
Cad
1 out of 5 stars review

Horrible tasting

Horrible tasting! If you notice, all of the good reviews are from a few years ago when their pies were really good and now they're pumpkin pie it's disgusting and unfortunately I would never buy it again unless they posted some kind of a sign that they have changed it back to the way it was a few years ago

Helpful?3U5EFX6MXV5T16262155253
Nov 14, 2018
Jon
1 out of 5 stars review

Pumpkin Pie

This year's pumpkin pie is horrible! I have bought several Sam's pumpkin pies in November for many years and loved them. But this year they changed the recipe. This year's pumpkin pie is gummy, too dense and has a strange after taste. I will NOT but another. Bring back last year's recipe.

Helpful?3U5EFX6MXV5T16262155253
Nov 13, 2011
pep02
1 out of 5 stars review

I used to say Sam's desserts are better than homemade why cook them. Now most of your baked goods are using high fructose corn syrup instead of sugar. It does make a taste difference.

Helpful?3U5EFX6MXV5T16262155253
Nov 10, 2018
NotGoodPie
1 out of 5 stars review

Gummy Pie

We served the pie to a group of 12. When we saw everyone's faces, we then tried it ourselves. We asked everyone if we could just throw it all away. It was horribly gummy. We will never buy this again.

Helpful?3U5EFX6MXV5T16262155253