The first roast we purchased was very good, but the second one was not, too much seasoning and too much fat in the roast. Therefore, inconsistent quality means we won't try another.

It was okay. Wasn't bad but wasn't completely amazing... then again what can you expect from something you can throw in the microwave? It's good for a quick go to in order to make a meal but it wouldn't be on my normal must haves list from Sam's.

Very good. I usually don't like things that come with gravy but this was very nice. I removed the gravy and then cooked potatoes, carrots and onion in it. Then I put the meat back and reheated. Just like home cooked!

Pleasantly surprised with the pot roast ! Very tender . A lot of gravy to serve with mashed potatoes . I will definitely purchase this again ! And we had enough for leftovers !!

The Members Mark pot roast and gravy is an excellent choice. The beef is extremely tender every time, the gravy tastes great, and the cooking for 13 minutes is effortless. I highly recommend this product.

For flavor and tenderness it meets the standard. Extremely flavorful and can be used with potatoes and carrots or in my case open roast beef sandwiches with steak fries.

I usually get this. It is normally a five star, The last time I bought it, it was tough, Usually it melts in my mouth, with the best taste ever. This time not so good.

Bought this because of the great reviews but won't be buying again. Ended up ordering pizza because 1) 3 lbs. of pot roast was more like 2 lbs. of gelatin with 1 lb of questionable roast 2) Smelled like dog food which made it difficult to eat 3) it's just bad. I have to wonder if anyone who likes this has ever had a good pot roast or if they were just paid. Says a 3 lb cooked roast but, even if we had liked it and eaten it all, it wouldn't have been enough for two people. The initial bites we ate before ditching it were way too salty and slimy. We chose the conventional oven heating method. Zero stars.

Sam's Club did away with carrying the Burnett packaged pot roast and started carrying their own version. The old brand way better. Not salty. No odd spice taste. The meat was better cooked and didn't seem to be as tough as Sam's version. I noticed it doesn't make the best leftovers either. It's not "bad", but it's not that home-made, slowcooker pot roast flavor like the Burnett's brand. BRING IT BACK!!! Won't see me buying this again anytime soon.

I've been purchasing this since it was sold by Burnett and MM had them package it for their selling.. Wasn't as good but not horrible either.. Purchased it last week and is like a solid piece of something but I don't know what.. You couldn't even pull it apart. yucky.. Bought one for a relative who is having a hard time right now and there is no way I would give that to him..I threw mine away and may return the one purchased for relative.. I hope this isn't another "step down" from what it used to be.. enough is enough.. Stop lowering your standards on what we eat..