The flavor is off. In no way do these taste like a girl scout cookie. Frosting was only on a small spot.

Absolutely nothing like girl scout cookies. The Carmel ones taste and smell like maple syrup so the these pop tarts became trash!

Was so excited to try these. The coconut caramel had a weird off putting flavor and I definitely didn't taste any coconut. Nothing like the cookies! Mint ones were ok, not very minty

Very disappointing. I had a mild freakout that I had Covid again because the thin mint literally has next to no flavor. The comment section here has assured me it's a feature not a fluke. As a long time scout, very sad flavor here.

These are terrible! Not sure if they were old, stuck in a transport truck too long or what but neither had filling first of all and tasted old. Glad I tried before my grandchildren had any. This is terrible POP TARTS!! So disappointed 😞

Contents are not as listed on the box - caramel & thin mint. Only thin mint in box. Sam's most likely bought this at a reduced rate, the entire lot, and is making hand over fist in profits selling it with box mislabeled

These were not as described which was disapointing considering they are made after my two favorite girlscout cookies. They taste nothing l Iike them they are dry and crumbly with barely any filling will be returning

The coconut caramel flavor was pretty good. Thin mint, not so much. I wouldn't buy them again.

Very faint flavor of both. Pretty much like eatting a plain pop tart.

Flavor is nothing like girlscout cookies