Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Member ratings & reviews for
Coffee-mate Italian Sweet Creme Liquid Coffee Creamer (64 fl. oz.)

Member photos

  • +220 images
Sort by |
Showing 71-80 of 2,929 reviews
Aug 4, 2024
Janet
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Add love

Everything else

Review from walmart.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Jul 28, 2025
A.M
2 out of 5 stars review

Stomach issue

Recently I have been having immediate stomach issues using this product and the dry version. There is a sour taste and clumping. I had to throw out 3 bottles of products. Wasted money!!

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Jan 14, 2024
Greg
1 out of 5 stars review

Was the greatest, now it's the worst

My wife and I have been buying Italians Sweet Cream for years now and we go through 2 big bottles a week. It's been a staple in our refrigerator and one that we recommended to everyone. Recently the taste has changed and it is absolutely terrible. I no longer enjoy it and am making a switch to International House Sweet Cream as it is the closest to what the Italian Sweet Cream that I loved. Why would Coffee Mate changed the flavor on an item that outsold every other flavor. If it isn't broke, don't fix it. I no longer will recommend this flavor to anyone.

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
reply from goodnespwr

We appreciate you reaching out. We made some changes to our Coffee mate Liquid Italian Sweet Crème flavor earlier this year with the goal to improve taste. We've received similar messages from other consumers, and we are sorry that it missed the mark for you. We've heard you and, in response, have decided to bring back the Italian Sweet Crème taste you know and love! Your favorite Italian Sweet Crème flavor will be available again at grocery stores nationwide for all sizes by January 2024. We hope you'll invite us back into your home again!

Dec 23, 2022
marybee1919
3 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Check order before delivery .

If you were new at this, like me, you must check your order to see if the item is out. I did not check the substitutions and it cost me three dollars more for four smaller bottles than my two bigger bottles. I wish they would have price matched. It cost me over three dollars more because of this error

Review from walmart.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Feb 1, 2024
Cindy
1 out of 5 stars review

Change Is Not Always Good

I used to love this creamer and told everyone about it. Now I cannot stand the new taste. After tasting it I threw the bottle away. When I was lucky enough to find some of the old flavor, I bought ever bottle the store had. Is there any talk of changing the taste back? I have not been able to enjoy my coffee since. PLEASE change it back...it was perfect the way it was.

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
reply from goodnespwr

We made some changes to our Coffee mate Liquid Italian Sweet Crème flavor earlier this year with the goal to improve taste. We've received similar messages from other consumers, and we are sorry that it missed the mark for you. We've heard you and, in response, have decided to bring back the Italian Sweet Crème taste you know and love! Your favorite Italian Sweet Crème flavor will be available again at grocery stores nationwide for all sizes by January 2024. We hope you'll invite us back into your home again!

Jan 22, 2024
Deb
1 out of 5 stars review

So upset

First, you get rid of Sweet Cream flavor - the only creamer I would use. Closest I could get to, and have had to bear it, was this Italian Sweet Cream. No, all of a sudden, it tastes weird/leaves funny taste in my mouth (similar to how your French Vanilla and others - horrible!). WHAT HAVE YOU DONE NOW?!?!??? And, of course, no mention of a change on your label. My over-sensitive taste buds can tell anything! Please fix this - I can't have my coffee if I can't get it to taste right - and I need my coffee!!! (wish you would just bring back Sweet Cream!!!)

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
reply from goodnespwr

We made some changes to our Coffee mate Liquid Italian Sweet Crème flavor earlier this year with the goal to improve taste. We've received similar messages from other consumers, and we are sorry that it missed the mark for you. We've heard you and, in response, have decided to bring back the Italian Sweet Crème taste you know and love! Your favorite Italian Sweet Crème flavor will be available again at grocery stores nationwide for all sizes by January 2024. We hope you'll invite us back into your home again!

Mar 4, 2024
Jessica502
1 out of 5 stars review

Soybean Oil Suckssss

I received a letter stating the original formula with vegetable oil would be back in January. It's March 4th and I've yet to find it anywhere. I'll just have to find a new brand at this point. You sent me free coupons that expire next month but I can't use them because the soybean version is disgusting and the original flavor was the only flavor I liked. :(

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
reply from goodnespwr

Thank you for reaching out and letting us know of your feedback. We've let our team know.

Mar 5, 2024
Smalls
1 out of 5 stars review

I will not be buying this product again

I was told 2 months ago the orginial creamer was coming back in stores in January 2024. Now it is march 5th and its not in stores yet. This creamer is the only one that didnt bother my stomach. Now i have to suffer with using milk. Please bring back the original italian creamer.

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
reply from goodnespwr

Thank you for reaching out to us! Your favorite Italian Sweet Crème flavor has returned to grocery stores nationwide for all sizes in January 2024. You can run a where to buy search at https://www.goodnes.com/coffeemate/products/italian-sweet-creme-liquid-coffee-creamer-32-oz-bottle/

Nov 25, 2024
caseya38_422063
5 out of 5 stars review

Great flavor!

I love this creamer, it has a great flavor and can be used in any kind of coffee! I have bought several times now it's definitely a favorite! Has a great creamy texture and the packaging is beautiful! And super sustainable, I love to keep the bottles and reuse to make Christmas crafts with my kids!

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Mar 3, 2025
Jen
1 out of 5 stars review

Why???

Why do you keep changing the recipes to my favorite creamer? About 15 years ago you did it to French vanilla. Maybe 3-4 years ago it was hazelnut. Now it is my all time favorite, italian sweet cream. Around 20 years ago you canceled amaretto. I probably bought around 2-3 gallons a month. Now I just don't want to go through taste testing till I find one I like. Found out that raw sugar and half and half taste real good and doesn't leave a film all over the inside of my mouth. p.S. I really don't care what the packaging looks like so long as what is in it is superior

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
reply from goodnespwr

We appreciate you reaching out to us and letting us know of your feedback. We've let our team know.