Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Member ratings & reviews for
Coffee-mate Italian Sweet Creme Liquid Coffee Creamer (64 fl. oz.)

Member photos

  • +220 images
Sort by |
Showing 261-270 of 2,932 reviews
Jul 30, 2023
LTMNY
1 out of 5 stars review

Disappointing

I buy 8 bottles at a time because that's all I have been drinking in my coffee for years. Something has changed drastically because it is now leaving a film on the top of my coffee and the flavor is not the same. I will now make my own (good recipes online).

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Oct 28, 2023
Thort041
1 out of 5 stars review

What did you do?

Okay, This used to be my favorite but something has changed! I hate it now! What is going on? I thought it was me so I looked it up and MANY people are having the same problem! I'm going to my second favorite until you fix this! Cold stone creamery (sweet cream)

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Oct 4, 2023
CooperTodd
1 out of 5 stars review

Cream tastes funny

I buy Sweet Italian Cream religiously! About a month ago bought my creamer as always and poured it into my coffee. It had a sour, horrible taste. Thought it was just me. I asked my mom and she said the same thing. Bought another bottle and the same thing. It just keeps getting worse. Every bottle seems to taste a little differently. I don't know what you've done but please fix it.

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Oct 7, 2023
TEKrat
1 out of 5 stars review

Why did you change it?

I have used this product for many years, but what have you done to it? I just bought three bottles and it has changed. It now tastes like it has something like pumpkin spice in it and it is horrible. This was the only creamer that I have used for more than five years and now I can't even stand the smell. You had a winner, why did you change it? Shame on you.

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Apr 11, 2021
ShyannAngel
1 out of 5 stars review

Tastes sour??

I just bought this and it definitely tastes likes it sour? Is this supposed to be the flavor? I've never had it so thankfully I only bought the small one but will not be using because I don't want to get sick of this isn't supposed to taste like this.....

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Oct 23, 2023
Leesmom
1 out of 5 stars review

Formula Changed to ARTIFICIAL flavor

Recent purchase says ARTIFICIALLY FLAVORED in small letters. UGH! My previous bottle was made with NATURAL flavors. The only reason I have used Italian Sweet Cream is because there wasn't an aftertaste. Now the aftertaste is DISGUSTING and doesn't go away long after using it in my coffee. FDA needs to step in and make Nestle be forthcoming with the changes in their formula for unsuspecting consumers.

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Mar 5, 2022
LeeD
1 out of 5 stars review

Artificial sweetener now added

I am so disappointed to see that all of the regular coffee mate liquid creamers now have sucralose. It tastes disgusting and will be going back to cream and sugar. Your company is not the only one to do this and I am highly disappointed as I can not consume any sweetener of this type.

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Jan 24, 2024
hank
1 out of 5 stars review

garbage

disgusting taste , original version was much better,,,

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
reply from goodnespwr

We made some changes to our Coffee mate Liquid Italian Sweet Crème flavor earlier this year with the goal to improve taste. We've received similar messages from other consumers, and we are sorry that it missed the mark for you. We've heard you and, in response, have decided to bring back the Italian Sweet Crème taste you know and love! Your favorite Italian Sweet Crème flavor will be available again at grocery stores nationwide for all sizes by January 2024. We hope you'll invite us back into your home again!

Sep 15, 2024
Rodrigo
5 out of 5 stars review

Please sell in Brazil

Every time I travel to the USA I bring a few bottles of liquid Italian saeet cream, but it runs out very quickly, please sell it in Brazil!

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Jul 8, 2020
Susan
1 out of 5 stars review

Has coffee mate changed the formula. I have bought the Itslian Sweet Cream for years. It has a sour taste. HORRIBLE

Review from walmart.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
reply from Coffee-mate ProductExpert

We're sorry to hear your creamer has this off sour taste, we've not reformulated this item. We'd like to hear more about your experience, please call us at 1-800-637-8534.- Michael, Coffee mate® Brand Ambassador.