Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Member ratings & reviews for
Coffee-mate Italian Sweet Creme Liquid Coffee Creamer (64 fl. oz.)

Member photos

  • +221 images
Sort by |
Showing 1,161-1,170 of 2,941 reviews
Jun 15, 2020
ChrissyP
1 out of 5 stars review

1 Star

Has the formula for the Italian Sweet Cream changed? We bought a bottle and it tasted sour, so we took it back to the store for a refund and purchased another bottle from a different store, same thing. Bought a third bottle from another store and it also tasted sour. I'm so disappointed, what happened?

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Oct 1, 2020
AtlantaCamps
5 out of 5 stars review

OMG Thank You

My mornings are complete again! My Nespresso Caramelito's are once again unbeatable. I was afraid after 6 bottles of bad Italian Sweet Cream that I would have to give up my morning Nespresso. Almost a month off the shelves. You guys obviously had a recall and problem that you didn't inform your customers of. The hundreds of complaints stating the same story in all states is pretty evident. However, the ISC is the best. Tried every other brand in the past month. Wasted several sleeves of pods. Lots of money down drain. So happy it's back and tasting the same. Wish you guys would've been more up front but you'll still keep getting my money.

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Sep 12, 2020
Carlyn
5 out of 5 stars review

Italian sweet cream

This is the only creamer I use. I have not found it to have a sour or metallic taste. Unfortunately though, I have just been to 5 different stores and can't find it anywhere. Please tell me it will be back on the shelves soon. Nothing else compares. I can't live without my coffee and cream:)

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Sep 6, 2020
Edie54
1 out of 5 stars review

Was my favorite

Just like everyone else I too bought several bottles of my favorite Italian Sweet Cream creamer only to have to throw them out very sour garlicky taste I thought it was just me. I miss the Italian sweet cream so very much. Went to store today absolutely no Italian Sweet cream, not that I would take a chance again at least until they get this problem fixed. Trying desperately to find a creamer for my coffee now.

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Jul 11, 2020
Brooklynkaaay
2 out of 5 stars review

Sour/Expired Taste

It seems like everyone else has the same problems! The last THREE bottles I bought tasted like they were out of date and absolutely horrible. I've been buying this creamer for years and this has never happened before until this week. All of these bottles has the Dec 2020 expiration date on them. I keep going to different stores and buying new bottles hoping for a different outcome, but it's the same taste no matter where I go. PLEASE FIX THIS!

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Mar 15, 2024
Anita
5 out of 5 stars review

It's the only flavor we use.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My husband and I both use Italian Sweet Creme Coffee Mate. It is our absolute favorite. It makes my coffee the perfect amount of sweetness and flavor. It goes well with all the different coffee flavors I use, too. I would, and do, recommend it to try it if you haven't already. It's perfect.

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Sep 21, 2023
PickyReader
3 out of 5 stars review

Did the formula change?

What happened to this creamer? I've been drinking this for about 10 years....yesterday I opened a new container and it tastes different. More like hazelnut or some other flavor. I exchanged them, hoping I just got a bad lot. But it's the same hazelnut or something flavor. Not happy and will not buy again.

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Jul 15, 2020
Tracee
1 out of 5 stars review

Flavor change

After reading other posts, I sadly believe something has gone terribly wrong with the quality of ingredients or bottling of the Italian Sweet Cream creamer. I have bought 6 bottles, both large & small, over the last 4 weeks and every single bottle of creamer has a soured taste. I thot maybe a store shipment got left out so I tried again and again only to find the latest bottle purchased this morning STILL has a foul, sour taste. Three people in our family drink it and everyone agrees something has changed with the quality of this creamer. PLEASE Coffee Mate, look into why this is happening and resolve whatever the problem is. I really miss my delicious Italian Sweet Cream coffee!

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Jan 27, 2021
Jthom21
2 out of 5 stars review

What's going on??

I got a Keurig in October 2020 and have been experimenting with different flavor combinations to find the absolute most perfect one. I found it. Dunkin's caramel coffee cake coffee, and Coffeemate's Italian Sweet Creme. I've told so many people. My second bottle, I accidentally purchased the store brand. It wasn't quite as good, but still pretty tasty. When I finally made it out to the store again (I barely leave the house due to the pandemic) I was super excited to get the coffeemate brand again, to experience the joy! Oh boy. I will suffer through many an ill advised flavor combination, but I had to actually dump out my coffee this morning and make a new cup with a different creamer. It tastes spoiled or maybe sugar free, but either way, super bad. I checked the bottle thinking maybe it had expired, but nope. Long before the best by date, and the actual creamer didn't smell or look curdled. It just tastes like crap. I googled "coffee mate creamer tastes bad" and immediately got a ton of Italian Sweet Creme reviews so I know I'm not alone. Maybe a transportation or storage issue? I'm so monumentally disappointed and since I don't really have the time or money to keep testing it out, especially given so many other customers keep having the same issue, I'm going back to the store brand. What a disappointment.

Review from goodnes.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
Dec 22, 2023
Rachel
1 out of 5 stars review

Horrible taste now.

You changed the recipe but didn't tell the public. It has a weird flavor that is awful tasting. Why change simething that was selling so well. You also put dairy in it. i am allergic to it. it was lactose free. i am very upset because this is our favorite creamer ever. please change back or lose a customer forever.

Review from walmart.com
Helpful?40JFLE7A8VVR14196352574
reply from Coffee-mate ProductExpert

We would like to learn more, so please call or text us at 1-800-637-8534.-Sabrina