my Giant schnauzer really loves them. she is not a chicken and beef kind of treat dog. she likes lamb and duck a lot. so good for her she loves them.

My little Cocker Spaniels LOVE these lamb sticks -- they get excited when I bring them out. They also love the Scottish salmon snacks.

My dobie is spoiled with his choices of treats. While he can be picky, and this is not in his top 5, he still likes them.

Good size and quantity similar to beef sticks easy. Sometimes a little dry.

None of 3 dogs, including a 180 lb Mastiff- who would eat a garbage truck if you let him-qoiod eat these.

Just awful. Hard treats. My goldens had no interest at all so I am returning them.