Used this for several years now. It doesn't smudge and doesn't give me eyelid irritation like lots of other mascaras. A more fluttery look than volumized look, but what I used to use now gives me a rash. Happy I found this.

Doesn't flake or smear or leave eyes black underneath

i love this mascara

My eyelashes fall out when I use this mascara. It dries in clumps and you have to scrub your lashes when you wash it off causing them to fall out. I do not recommend this product.

Dries hard and breaks off in chunks.