Good, but really with the whipped topping was actual whip cream. The oily substitute never tastes right

Just as good or better than Baker’s Square French Silk pie! Also a much better value since this is a 12” pie.

This pie is delicious! The chocolate is deep and smooth. It is quite big so will feed many people. I hope Sam’s keeps it in stock year round.

The filling tastes like containing wine and salty, nothing even close to creamy and decadent as touted in the description, a huge disappointment!!

I bought these for Christmas day gathering. Both pies were amazing.. way to big so everyone took some home

We used to love the 9" satin pie. Tasted great and it was a 5 star value @$8.99. This 12" replacement is way too big and much more $. It seems to be a different consistency (richer)

This was one of the best French Silk pies I've ever eaten! The chocolate flavor was rich and the texture was so smooth and creamy, with just the right density.

Love this pie, very tasty, very rich and good. My only problem is that it is TOO big! 12" pie is hard to cut small pieces, and this pie is so rich that I don't want a huge piece. Would prefer a smaller 9" pie at a lower price so I can cut a piece that is small enough to enjoy.

First time buying this. I had dental wok done and needed something soft to eat. I tried several chocolate cream pies. They were ok. Bought this one an it was very good. Better than all the rest i tried. Only con is that it is so big it took awhile to eat it all!

Have you ever tasted your dream pie? I have, this SAMs club Chocolate Cream pie is silkie smooth like a velvety chocolate mousse pudding! It has such a lite creamy fluffy chocolatey smooth taste and there isn't a bakery anywhere that can come close to this beautiful creation! You can not beat the price either! My absolute favorite cream pie that is affordable!!