I bought these thinking they were the same thin mint brownies from last year. They are totally different. The look is different and the taste is very different. Last year's were soft and fudgy with good flavor, this year's are hard, dry, crumbly, and the mint flavor is all you can taste. Minus 1/4 brownie, the whole thing went in the trash.

The mint is so strong, chocolate taste is weak. So it needs less mint and more rich chocolate flavor. However, I like it because when I cut each brownie into 8 pieces, that small size more resembles the mint flavor blast I get from a thin mint cookie. In that small portion, it really needs a booster shot of chocolate. I would buy these again with more chocolate flavor and in a smaller size, like a mini-brownie format.

Gross

Imagine dry potting soil mixed with toothpaste, that's what these brownies taste like. They were so bad that I returned them and got my money back.

Dry and with a nasty mint taste. Sam's Club bakery items are usually very good but they missed the mark with these.

I needed another dessert for Thanksgiving and these brownies looked good and were on sale. Sad to say they were very dry and even the grandchildren didn't like them.

Really enjoyed these brownies, especially with a nice glass of milk. Mint flavor was spot on with Girl Scout's! Crunchy cookie topping on top of a moist brownie.

These tasted like toothpaste at best. Very dry. I love thin mints and this was definitely nowhere close in flavor. I ate 1.5 brownies before tossing the whole thing.

Save your money, we threw them out. Instead of cutting brownies that were iced - this junk was baked in a form mini baking pans. DRY and no icing, just a drizzle of the mint stuff. Awful, didn't even qualify as a brownie. Here Sams goes again! Eliminated the good stuff to try to push their higher margin sub par junk.

This time they were very dry. In the past they were really good