I bought thinking they would taste good, no flavor at all. My daughter who loves sweets didn't even eat the whole cookie.

They're cute but not impressive flavor for the cookie and the chocolate is pretty thick. They were fun once but not worth getting again.

Shortbread isn't really flavorful so that is about what I expected but the icy is thick and waxy. Lovely presentation for summer BBQ though!!

I have been waiting for 2 years to find these cookies. They are the best. They need them year round with all the other holidays…. Valentines , St. Patrick’s, Halloween, Christmas…

I absolutely LOVE these Members Mark iced coated shortbread cookies. I've been searching for them for since 2020, after I bought the Halloween decorated version. Please keep these coming in all their seasonal versions.

I will never buy these cookies again. Waste of money! These were hard and covered with a thick, waxy icing. They had no flavor compared to traditional shortbread cookies. Do not buy these!!

LOVE these cookies. Wish they were available all year -- in any cutout shape. The icing is not too sweet like some cookies. I bought about 10 packages and gave some as gifts! They are large cookies and don't look cheap.

Ignore the negative reviews because these were a hit at my 4th of July barbecue. The whole pack was gone within minutes of putting them out and everyone asked where I bought them. They are so tasty and even better after they get a little cold in the refigerator.

I bought these to take to a Memorial Day picnic we were attending. I thought they were so pretty and festive. Unfortunately, they were so bad tasting that a lot of them ended up in the garbage and they were far from cheap. I would not recommend these cookies. The taste and texture of these cookies was very "artificial". I wouldn't have felt so cheated with the high price if they had tasted better. Sam's has better things to choose from.

I wouldn't buy them again. No flavor to them