These cookies are NASTY! Super hard and taste nasty! Don't waste your $$$. They look pretty but that's it!

They're cute but not impressive flavor for the cookie and the chocolate is pretty thick. They were fun once but not worth getting again.

I bought thinking they would taste good, no flavor at all. My daughter who loves sweets didn't even eat the whole cookie.

Shortbread isn't really flavorful so that is about what I expected but the icy is thick and waxy. Lovely presentation for summer BBQ though!!

LOVE these cookies. Wish they were available all year -- in any cutout shape. The icing is not too sweet like some cookies. I bought about 10 packages and gave some as gifts! They are large cookies and don't look cheap.

I will never buy these cookies again. Waste of money! These were hard and covered with a thick, waxy icing. They had no flavor compared to traditional shortbread cookies. Do not buy these!!

I absolutely LOVE these Members Mark iced coated shortbread cookies. I've been searching for them for since 2020, after I bought the Halloween decorated version. Please keep these coming in all their seasonal versions.

I have been waiting for 2 years to find these cookies. They are the best. They need them year round with all the other holidays…. Valentines , St. Patrick's, Halloween, Christmas…

Ignore the negative reviews because these were a hit at my 4th of July barbecue. The whole pack was gone within minutes of putting them out and everyone asked where I bought them. They are so tasty and even better after they get a little cold in the refigerator.

Tender, moist and pretty. But they could use more vanilla flavor !