Love everything bagels

Bagel shop quality

Terrible

Original type Bagels

Good

awesome flavor

Firstly these are NOT "Everything" bagels - unless you think poppy seeds and sesame seeds are "everything". No onion flakes, no garlic bits, they used powdered instead and you can't taste the flavor of either onion or garlic. So. NOT everything, more like "Hardly Anything Bagels". Secondly these are extremely dry and badly partially pre-sliced bagels. The slice is weird, it never goes even halfway through, and it is ALWAYS ALWAYS ALWAYS off center so you get one super skinny side and one fat side - or more usually, it's lopsided so part of each half is fat and the other part is skinny. Does NOT lend itself to even toasting. They have almost no flavor and they are dry dry dry. Will not be buying again.

The description says New York style boiled bagels; these bagel do not have the texture of a boiled bagel, They are pretty much the same as supermarket "roll with a hole" bagel in taste and texture. The only advantage over supermarket is, these are cheaper. But, I wanted a good bagel not a cheap one. Lender's frozen are better than these.

I was skeptical of these bagels but thought it was time to give them a try. They were close in flavor and texture to Jewish deli bagels and far better than Dunkin Donuts bagels (which I used to consider good enough when I couldn’t get the real thing). Other grocery store bagels aren’t even in the same ballpark as these. On top of that these really are a great value.

The first few times we purchased these they were great with actual everything bagel seasoning. Now it seems like someone has tried to recreate the actual everything bagel seasoning and has missed horribly. The actual seasoning has more than just sesame seeds and poppy seeds. Thank God I have some actual everything bagel seasoning to spice these up or they would be trash.