Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Diet Dr Pepper 12 fl. oz., 30 pk. for
Diet Dr Pepper 12 fl. oz., 30 pk.
4.3 out of 5 stars
stars
376 ratings367 reviews
  1. 5 stars73% (274)
  2. 4 stars11% (42)
  3. 3 stars4% (14)
  4. 2 stars2% (9)
  5. 1 star10% (37)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 41-50 of 367 reviews
May 11, 2023
Reviewer name: kmen
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Yuck lately

I am a Dr.Pepper lover and have been for more years than I can remember! Something has changed with the flavor and carbonation of the last 3-4 12 packs I have purchased. I can't even get a 1\2 can down and I am usually a 1-2 can a day gal! What did you do? I won't be drinking again until assured of a good product.

Review from Dr Pepper
Helpful?3HHV4RDD7TAR13621807259
Aug 6, 2020
Reviewer name: Piddles
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Made with Adpartame

I wish you would make Dr Pepper with Stevia or even Swerve. I would gladly pay more for it. Aspartame gives me headaches and leaves a yucky film in my mouth. I buy Dr Zevia, it's sweet enough but lacks the true flavor of Dr Pepper. I shall keep looking and hoping for a diet drink sweetened with Stevia which is made from the plant Stevia.

Review from Dr Pepper
Helpful?3HHV4RDD7TAR13621807259
Nov 27, 2016
Reviewer name: Granny o3
2 out of 5 stars
2 out of 5 stars review

Great taste...highly addictive !!!

DIet Dr. Pepper..Best tasting soft drink ever, but highly addictive ! Once you start drinking then you can't stop, you have to have them. After they destroy your teeth and your kidneys you want to stop, but you can't. You go to great lengths to find your next "fix". They should be outlawed !!

Review from Dr Pepper
Helpful?3HHV4RDD7TAR13621807259
Dec 15, 2019
Reviewer name: Danny
4 out of 5 stars
4 out of 5 stars review

Taste

My wife and I have been avid Diet Dr Pepper consumers for over 45 years. It has been a very good beverage. However, more and more lately, (past year) we have time and time again purchased Diet Dr Pepper that has been ill fated with the flavor. Some so bad we have had to throw it out. I am sure this is a quality control issue, and we can only hope that when the bad mixtures are produced, that they Do Not reach the public. Ugh. We now find ourselves “Hoping” it’s a good batch when we purchase. also, please make the Expiration Dates plainly visible on the 24 packs. This too has been an issue. We love the flavor of this drink and can only hope that in the future you will pay special attention to the correct flavor as it leaves your facility, and legible expiration dates on packaging. Thank you.

Review from Dr Pepper
Helpful?3HHV4RDD7TAR13621807259
Mar 15, 2023
Reviewer name: Cherb2
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Bad taste and smell

Last three cases I bought from two different stores, I've had to return due to the soda has a smell and horrible taste. There was a recall last year because of this. I believe all the tainted soda was not returned to distributor and that was sold to us.

Review from Dr Pepper
Helpful?3HHV4RDD7TAR13621807259
Nov 6, 2020
Reviewer name: Sherry Dienges
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Great Drink

I have enjoyed Diet Dr. Pepper for over 20 years But i am getting pretty tired of not being able to find the 24 pks in the stores anymore and then they hike the price of 12 pks. You can find everything else but Diet Dr. Pepper. I am seriously thinking of switching to something else because of the availability

Review from Dr Pepper
Helpful?3HHV4RDD7TAR13621807259
Dec 13, 2020
Reviewer name: Verifiedserialkiller
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Mildew smelling bottle and cap

First of all Diet Dr Pepper is normally my fave thing. I recently moved from CO to OK and noticed the last few 20oz bottles that I have picked up smell like mildew. The caps and the bottle opening have a very strong mildew odor. I am not sure if this is machinery related or if it's something else?? Hopefully this information will help. The stamp on the bottle is LO325DP3 18:55 and the bar code DP-0105 DPAC.04018G ...if this had been one bottle I'd say it was a one off...I had my boyfriend smell the cap and he said that it smells like mildew as well so it wasn't just me.

Review from Dr Pepper
Helpful?3HHV4RDD7TAR13621807259
Oct 22, 2024
Reviewer name: MWNesbit
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Oreo-flavor Dr Pepper Sugar-Free would by purchase

I'm a DP drinker of more than 60 years - about to celebrate BD #69 in two weeks! Around 20 years ago, my doctor began the appeal to start removing as much real-sugar product from diet as possible - especially items with corn syrup/high fructose levels. Switch to Diet DP was fairly seamless - really the only true "diet" product that retains as close to the same flavor as regular DP!! That said, I don't stray from Diet DP very often - mainly when I find myself somewhere that doesn't serve DP products at all. Along with switching to Diet DP, I have begun a gradual tapering of how many either 16.9 or 20 oz. products I allow myself per day - usually only one, but am now tapering to 3-4 a week if possible due to increased glucose levels. I was at a convenience store last week and saw a new flavor of Dr Pepper [in fact I believe there were 3-4 new "flavored" DP brands in the freezer. The one that caught my attention was Oreo Dr. Pepper,Sugar-Free which were packaged in 12 oz. cans. I knew that I wanted to try this flavored DP drink, being that one of my other "food/drink addictions" are Oreos! In addition, the tming worked out really well because my younger sister and B-I-L were in town for a short visit. I purchased 4 - 12 oz cans of our Oreo flavored DP Sugar-Free and brought them home so we could sample them and see if this was a good blending of two of my/our favorite things, or if it ma not meet up to expectations.!?! BTW- I very rarely stray from the original flavor due to the fat that I drink Diet DP for one reason only - I like the way it tastes - and I don't want that "taste" to be changed or altered in an way if possible [I believe we call this a 'traditionalist']. Finally to the point of this review: After dinner that evening as the four of us [Wife & I and Sister & Brother in Law] were sitting and talking - and letting dinner tastes & smells settle - I brought out the four DP Oreo Sugar-Free flavored cans and, basically, became an interviewer/reviewer of this new product known as Oreo Dr Pepper Sugar-Free. I asked all to treat it as close to a testing environment as possible [without trying to be weird or pretentious about it. (BTW - none of the four of us are alcohol drinkers in any form). Anyway - 1) sniff/aroma test before actually tasting the beverage product; 2) brief sip test and write down initial thoughts on aroma and taste; 3) - brief fuller taste test and write down how closely the product tasted like Dr Pepper, if it was possible to taste an Oreo flavor at all - and to what level; if the flavor was not distinctively of Dr Pepper, what was the flavor each person was getting from the three simple tests of our survey?? Technically, there was a fourth question of my survey, and that was "would you purchase this product again - even if it were merely to do another fair sampling of the product?? So - our initial taste testing of the new product Oreo flavored Dr Pepper Sugar-Free had the following results: Wife - [not a real traditionalist, nor as big a fan as I regrading DP] - Sniff test = sensed first a chocolate smell (faint) and then a little stronger vanilla smell - ultimately it reminded her of the smell of a chocolate chip cookie or brownie as it was cooling; both sip & taste test = were the same - she felt it tasted much like a creme soda drink. Brother-In-Law - [a regular Diet DP drinker] - Sniff test = a creme' type of aroma, but not particularly similar to a creme soda smell - mainly that it didn't have an aroma like Dr Pepper at all. Sip & Taste tests = both the same impressions - again the flavoring of some type of creme' product, but not really distinctive enough to tell - and did not taste anh of the 'traditional' Dr Pepper flavorings that cause him to drink Dr Pepper/Diet Dr Pepper in the first place. Sister - [an occasional drinker of Diet DP, but also drinks Coke Zero] - Sniff test = she smelled/sensed some chocolate aromas, and felt that at least the aroma led her to believe that it might not taste like a "diet or sugar free product. Her sip & taste tests = pretty much mirrored her responses to the sniff test. She tasted some faint DP taste, but actually couldn't really tell if was a diet Dr Pepper product, or a diet Coke product. Finally, it was my turn to review [as stated - a traditionalist, long-time DP & diet DP drinker] Sniff test = really not a distinctive smell for me (admittedly a sufferer from hay fever and exposure to ragweed which is high this time of year in Texas - so olfactory senses are not always accurate). I really did not expect to get much aroma smell knowing my own lack of ability to discern many smells at all. Sip Test = I suppose I was disappointed from the beginning of the sip test that I did not taste ANY distinctive aroma or taste, either a Dr Pepper nor an Oreo aroma or taste!! The more full taste test proved to be even more disappointing, in that I could not make out any discernable taste or aroma that reminded me of either of the two food/drink combos that I/we were searching for in this taste testing experiment. Eventually, before completely finishing the product, I was able to discern a bit of a chocolate overtone flavor, but never any type of aroma/taste overall satisfaction that I was, in fact, drinking and tasting a product that was equally discernable to be both a classic Dr Pepper taste & aroma, but that or an Oreo cookie taste of mixed Chocolate & vanilla creme' filling. At the end of my "Very Unofficial Product Review of Oreo-Flavored Dr Pepper Sugar-Free", I aske one final question of my three family members and myself - "Would you buy this product if it were available in regular Grocery and Convenience stores close to you?? Unfortunately, the overwhelming answer to this question was ( and remains to be) NO!!!

Review from Dr Pepper
Helpful?3HHV4RDD7TAR13621807259
Sep 22, 2023
Reviewer name: Holda66
2 out of 5 stars
2 out of 5 stars review

Disappointed of late!

I have been a diet Dr Pepper fan for as long as I can. Remember! I love the product, however, as of late I’d say in the last 3 to 4 months, about a third of any product I buy is flat. I’m getting tired of throwing out a lot of diet Dr Pepper. Please do something about this!!! I want to be a satisfied customer again.

Review from Dr Pepper
Helpful?3HHV4RDD7TAR13621807259
Feb 6, 2025
Reviewer name: Kathys
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Bad product

I have been drinking diet Dr pepper for the last twenty years.i have found if you get them to close to the expiration dates they turn to a metal flavoring so I always get the newest bottles with the longest dates. This time I got eight bottles with the date April 7,2025. When I opened it up it was awful it was so bad I can't drink it. I guess I'm going to have to find a different drink I'm not paying for something I can't even drink. I opened a second bottle hoping it was just the one but it was bad to. Did you have a bad batch go out?

Review from Dr Pepper
Helpful?3HHV4RDD7TAR13621807259