I give the brown leather sandals 5 stars. The black sandals, maybe 3 stars. The straps on the brown ones are a nice, soft, substantial, REAL leather. The straps on the black are absolutely not real leather, they don't look, feel, behave or smell like leather; they look, feel, behave and smell like cheap vinyl pleater, which is what they are. I would buy the brown ones again for sure, but if you want real leather straps, the black will leave you disappointed. As for the brown ones, which I have been wearing for over a week straight now, they are great! Comfortable, true to size and it seems like the arch support improves as they form to your feet. I have a very high arch and I have not experienced any of the high arch issues with these (like toe and foot cramping). The leather straps on the brown ones are soft, break in easily, and haven't rubbed raw spots or blisters anywhere. I may try to return the black ones as I want real leather, but I also wanted these in the black color, so I will sleep on it for a day or 2.

My second pair. I still am wearing the pair I bought 5 to 6 years ago. After trying similar shoes at stores, none come close; they are fake leather, stiff and uncomfortable. These Mountain Sole sandals have butter-soft leather, and are indestructible. Sam's don't ever stop selling these!

I bought these in the black and brown last summer. Wore them most every day and so far this year. Holding up just great. I usually wear a 8-1/2 wide and the 8 medium fits perfect. Most comfortable sandal I've ever sandal and well made. And leather to boot! Am so glad they've added two new colors this year. Can't wait to get my order. Thanks Sam's Club!!!

I really needed a new pair of sandals since the summer is right around the corner. I stumbled upon these shoes and I’m very impressed. The soles on the shoes are soft! They have a soft texture & have great arch support. I love these so much considering I have a toddler to chase these were still so comfy compared to other brands. I went back and bought two more pairs. These are amazing shoes! Just buy them!

It's definitely not the same quality as the more expensive brand but for the cheap price it's worth it. I got the brown one in the store, and the sides of the leather are a bit rough which seems to be breaking in. Underside is soft enough. The foot bed is very flat and wide with hardly any arch support. I'm fine with that so I'm keeping these.

These sandals are very comfortable after wearing all day, and well worth the price. They run true to size. I purchased them in black, brown and white. I have a very high arch in my feet and these work well for me. They are leather, unlike another popular brand name that sale for at least $85 more. I have not had any problems with them being too wide, too tight, staying on my feet, putting sores on my feet or stretching out. I highly recommend these sandals.

I bought my first pair a couple of months ago and loved them so much that i then purchased them on white. They are so comfortable and you can't beat the price. I just saw that they are now marked down so i bought them in black, and just for good measure i also bought a pair of the double strapped ones. All in all i got 4 very comfortable great quality sandals for less than it would have cost me to buy a single pair of birkenstocks! Yes!!! Ladies, don't hesitate, just buy them! You won't be sorry

I buy multiple pairs of these every spring to last me all year. They only sell these a few months of the year, but I wear them everyday. They are just as good as the big brand names but at a fraction of the cost. I highly recommend them. It is hard to find this style sandal with actual leather straps.

Very uncomfortable. Holes don't seem notched in good places for decent for. Not for me.

I ordered the white pair in a size 9, and the right shoe was shorter in length than the left one. Two stars for poor quality control. They are sold out and I can't re-order them.