I'll give it a 3 star because I didn't get to use them in the summer. Even though these were recommended, they are not for Chicago winters, as stated in the description "Summer tires". Guess I won't know how they are in the summer, because I am exchanging them. Could not get out of my own driveway after it snowed a couple inches and when I did, I slid down the road that had a 1% grade!