Screwball Whiskey is known for its unique peanut butter flavor profile. Reviews often praise its sweet and nutty taste, making it stand out in the whiskey category. Some enjoy its smoothness, while others find it a delightful addition to cocktails or even on the rocks. It's essential to note that individual preferences vary, and some may find the flavor distinctive or an acquired taste. For the most accurate and detailed reviews, checking online liquor retailers, whiskey enthusiast forums, or professional spirits reviews can provide insights into how well Screwball Whiskey aligns with your taste preferences.

I always buy "premium" whiskey and very rarely did I buy flavored whiskey but this was recommended to me and I instantly went out and bought it. At first glance, the bottle is simple which is very appealing to me. It smells great! On its own it's pretty good however when used as a mixer magical things happen. First I put it in hot chocolate and it was so delicious. The delicious peanut butter flavor with the mild and gentle whiskey flavor was absolutely perfect in the hot chocolate. Then I decided to make a "peanut buster parfait" style milk shake using this whiskey and oh my goodness, it was incredible! I don't think this has an intense after burn like some whiskey and I think it has the perfect peanut butter flavor. I haven't tried any other peanut butter flavored alcohol but I don't think I would find one that is as good or better than this one. I purchased it at the PA State Store so I paid more than average for it but I think it was worth every penny. If you love peanut butter and are willing to drink whiskey, I definitely recommend trying this if you get the opportunity!!!!!

I'm obsessed. I was super skeptical about the thought of peanut butter whiskey but this stuff is awesome. After I tried it I couldn't stop thinking about it. It almost has a caramel coffee like taste to me. It's hard to describe it but it's good! I love pouring myself a small glass after dinner and call it dessert since it's so sweet.

I love this peanut butter whiskey, and I'm not even a whiskey drinker. I was trying to introduce family in florida to peanut butter whiskey and they didn't have this brand the other 2 brands we tried were trash. Stick to skrewball! It's great for shots and recently I discovered a peanut butter cup martini < 3

I’m obsessed. I was super skeptical about the thought of peanut butter whiskey but this stuff is awesome. After I tried it I couldn’t stop thinking about it. It almost has a caramel coffee like taste to me. It’s hard to describe it but it’s good! I love pouring myself a small glass after dinner and call it dessert since it’s so sweet.

Love this whiskey it is literally my favorite of everything I’ve tried I’ve drank so many bottles haha (unhealthy) but seriously some people say it’s overpowering in the peanut butter taste but I think it’s very settle and goes down easy I could literally chug it if I wanted to it’s so smooth!

I love experimenting with this alcohol and making new cocktails and pairings that I think will work great with it. I also love getting my friends and families reactions on trying this different but new type of alcohol as it just bring out the best reactions.

I think that this peanut butter whiskey is best ice cold; i keep mine in the freezer. Straight up@ the taste is very smooth when cold! If you're more of a mixed drink person, I've found that mixing it with Dr. Pepper results in a reeces peanut butter drink! Excellent as a standalone shot or as a mixed drink, and one of my new favorites!

I always like to buy the little sample bottles so I can try new things. I'm so glad I tried this one! I'm obsessed with this whiskey now. It tastes like peanut butter without being overly peanut buttery. It's sweet but not too sweet. It doesn't burn your throat. I drink it on ice. It's that's good. I'm ashamed to tell you how many bottles I've bought. Do yourself a favor and try it.

I got this as a gift for my bestie and tried a sip and OMG. This is delicious, tastes just like a Reese's with the rich warmth of whiskey. My friend used it to make a white Russian and loved it. A bit costly but it's so flavorful you're not gunna drink a lot at a time. Loved it.