4 out of 5 stars because 4 out of 5 cookies were great. Red Velvet - Basically a red chocolate chip. S'mores - love the flavor/texture combo Vanilla Shortbread - these were not great. EVERY SINGLE ONE of them were in pieces. They were broken, bland, and the texture wasn't good. They were slightly under cooked. Chewy Ginger - always my favorite. You can never have too much ginger. You could leave the sugar crystals off, I just want the ginger and spices. Turtle Brownie - chocolate, caramel and pecans. Yum! Could use a few more pecans. Fix the shortbread recipe or better yet replace the shortbread with chocolate chunk and this combo pack would be perfect.

Cookies turned very stale about a day after I bought them

These cookies are delicious!

Weren’t as fresh as we expected

My coworkers love these cookies!

Great value, great variety, soft cookies

all flavors were delicious

Undercooked and falls apart in pieces when picking them up.

Good

Delicious!