I gave it three stars because we liked three out of the five cookies. Nobody cared for the shortbread cookies. the two best were the first one, Cookie Butter, which tastes more like a soft cinnamon cookie, and the last one which is exactly what it says, a pumpkin cookie with white chocolate chunks. In third place is the Cranberry Dream which is a cranberry orange cookie with white chocolate chunks. A little disappointed because we purchased this for a large family Christmas party and we are left with all the shortbread cookies that nobody likes.

I read reviews before buying these cookies..I have made my own for 50 yrs. but not up to it this yr. decided 2 buy.. Anyone who is a decent baker would NOT care for these cookies..not even close to having a good homemade taste..Mostly all taste the same..not much butter or vanilla flavor in any of them.. I did think the cranberry cookies would pass but that is the only one i cared for at all..I have thru the yrs havent found 2 many store bought cookies that are very good.. I have found cookies at our Meijer store that are closer to a homemade cookie than any i have ever tried..peanutbutter especially.. Think after all these yrs this is the worst complaint..and its not just them..like i mentiond..finding good bakery cookies in a store isnt likely, i havent yet and Im not going 2 waste my money trying again..way 2 expensive for that..

We tried to support a new bakery product for the holiday and were not impressed at all. They were so disappointing. Not a good cookie on the tray!!! The light brown one with sugar crystals looked and tasted like a soft baked gingerbread cookie but it was labeled as a cookie butter cookie. It was o-kay.

Incredible holiday flavors! Sophisticated - not to sweet. Great texture, better than many homemade cookies Ive eaten in every aspect. Bought them for a party - they were all gone by the end of the night! My only request - sell them in a smaller package as well as the big tray for smaller families to enjoy. The big tray is too much. Best seasonal cookies you can buy!

For being a store-bought cookie tray, I was blown away by these. Each of these flavors was better than I expected. The shortbread cookies were sooooo delicious. The millionaire's bar was divine! And the cookie butter… oh my word. There's pieces of orange in the cranberry cookie. I mean. Come on. This will seriously wow at any holiday gathering!

These were a crowd pleaser for sure! Something for everyone!

Very delicious cookies, will buy again!!!

The dough for all the cookie flavors tasted the same...awful cookies!

The hot coco and smore cookies were fire!!

Love the different varieties!