The flavor was fine. It wasn't chocolate sandwich cookies, just plain chocolate cookies. The vanilla ice cream has very gritty texture. Not ice crystals, but grit that doesn't dissolve. Very strange. Disappointing as most Members Mark items taste delicious.

These are a Magnum knock off and boy did I have high hopes, but if you've recently had a Magnum you'll probably find them disappointing. I know I did. As time passes from eating that Magnum they do get better but still pale in comparison taste-wise. A plus is the price as they're certainly more reasonable than Magnums, but will I buy again based on taste ... not likely.

I WILL BUY AGAIN GOOD PRICE ALOT OF CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIES TO

Horrible flavor and gritty. Not going to buy ever again. Not worth the money.

The taste was great, the adults enjoyed it as well as the kids. Most definitely will buy again! The price for this icecream is a great value.

I love cookies and cream ice cream and at $6$$$ and some change I can afford to buy like 8 of these pails of ice cream a month

In the words of my 2 year old “Mommy.. mmmm it good!”. Wouldn’t have imagined this ice cream tasting so good!

This is very good cookies and cream ice cream So many pieces and cookies crumbs. Would buy again

I was nervous buying such a large size at 5 qts thinking it wouldnt be good. I was shocked how good it was. The price is great and so is the taste!

My husband loves oreo, milk and ice cream. Knowing he's eating all his favorite and they have chuck's of cookies. He is enjoying this ice cream