This ice cream was very grainy and did not have a creamy ice cream texture. We were really disappointed because most Member’s Mark items we have purchased are comparable to other brands. We will not buy this again!

This is so good & my self discipline goes out the door when I know it’s in my freezer. You don’t get that gooey, oily taste. The quality is really good but not so good for a diabetic. If I want to eat this I have to move around my carbs to eat that day. Still, it’s a good reward treat. The chocolate cookie bits are tasty and crunchy. Please buy it and have a bowl for me.

The ice cream had a very gritty texture. It was so bad that no one (not even my teens) wanted to eat it so I ended up having to throw it away. I did try it and it was good but the texture was a powdery. Anyways I hate throwing money away but had to. I read that this happens because it either melted and then refroze or it was made cheaply. I'm going to go with it probably just melted at some point during it's travels to my Sam's club.

We usually get bluebell ice cream and are always looking for cheaper Brands for our big family and try this because we all love Oreo ice cream and this has got some seriously big Oreo chunks! One of the best Oreo ice creams we’ve tried and the price and size is great!!!!

Have purchased 2x this summer. Excellent value: good taste, loaded with cookie chunks, creamy. (Not sure why one review says "sandy" and another "hard to scoop"? No issues w either.) Better than most cookies 'n cream ice creams on the market. Perfect if you have kids in terms of value--it's over a gallon! Wish Member's Mark also had a vanilla bean in a 5 qt pail.

I usually am not one to write reviews but I was on the fence about this ice cream because the cheap price. We bought this to try for my twins first birthday coming up and it’s so good!! Very creamy and the cookies are so soft. They almost taste like ice cream sandwich cookie!

In our home cookies and cream is our favorite. We typically all go into an icecream shop and 3 outta 5 of us order cookies and cream. That's a pricey visit if the majority of us order the same thing and we all like it. For 7 bucks, it's a bargain and we LOVE the quality. Big hunks of cookies and good tasting icecream. Other brands taste like ice milk, this tastes more like cream. Yum!

Wow, this is great ice cream especially for the price. Whenever I go out for ice cream I always get an Oreo blizzard or whatever that shop’s equivalent. I love the taste of cookies and cream and this does NOT disappoint. The texture is more creamy than the members mark vanilla also and it’s a bit softer. Easier to scoop frozen.

I was surprised how good this ice cream was. We went and bought another tub of it.

Granddaughter loves the taste. I love the price