In 1000+ people's carts
Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 24 pk.
Item # 171816
Current price is USD$10.94
$0.23/oz
Prices may vary in club and online
Shipping
Free for Plus on eligible orders over $50
Columbus, 43215
Return or replace anytime.
SNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery only
Get a $30 statement credit¹ when you open an account 9/1-9/30/26 + learn how to earn 10% back on fuel for a limited time‡ See details
Highlights
We also recommend
KIND Max Crispy Protein Bars, Chocolate Peanut Butter, 14 ct., $17.98, $1.28/ea
$1798
current price $17.98$1.28/ea
KIND Max Crispy Protein Bars, Chocolate Peanut Butter, 14 ct.
4.1192 out of 5 stars
Sponsored
Hero image 0 of Nutter Butter Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies, 24 pk., 0 of 10
Members also considered
Pillsbury Soft Baked Mini Chocolate Chip Cookies, 1.5 oz., 28 pk., $11.92, $0.28/oz
Sponsored$1192current price $11.92$0.28/ozPillsbury Soft Baked Mini Chocolate Chip Cookies, 1.5 oz., 28 pk.
18614.4535 out of 5 Stars. 1861 reviews4.4535 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup, Delivery or ShippingPickupDeliveryShippingNabisco Sweet Treats Variety Pack, 60 pk., $13.98, $0.30/oz
$1398current price $13.98$0.30/ozNabisco Sweet Treats Variety Pack, 60 pk.
54224.7016 out of 5 Stars. 5422 reviews4.7016 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup, Delivery or ShippingPickupDeliveryShippingFamous Amos Chocolate Chip Cookies, 2 oz., 42 pk., $18.38, $0.22/oz
$1838current price $18.38$0.22/ozFamous Amos Chocolate Chip Cookies, 2 oz., 42 pk.
45904.7991 out of 5 Stars. 4590 reviews4.7991 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup, Delivery or ShippingPickupDeliveryShippingOREO Chocolate Sandwich Cookies, 2.4 oz., 30 pk., $13.48, $0.19/oz
$1348current price $13.48$0.19/ozOREO Chocolate Sandwich Cookies, 2.4 oz., 30 pk.
128334.8024 out of 5 Stars. 12833 reviews4.8024 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup, Delivery or ShippingPickupDeliveryShippingLorna Doone Shortbread Cookies 1.5 oz., 30 pk., $11.98, $0.27/oz
$1198current price $11.98$0.27/ozLorna Doone Shortbread Cookies 1.5 oz., 30 pk.
32964.8037 out of 5 Stars. 3296 reviews4.8037 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup, Delivery or ShippingPickupDeliveryShippingNabisco Cookie Variety Pack, 30 pk., $13.78, $0.23/oz
$1378current price $13.78$0.23/ozNabisco Cookie Variety Pack, 30 pk.
7984.6754 out of 5 Stars. 798 reviews4.6754 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup, Delivery or ShippingPickupDeliveryShippingKnott's Berry Farm Strawberry Shortbread Cookies, 2 oz., 36 pk., $11.58, $0.16/oz
$1158current price $11.58$0.16/ozKnott's Berry Farm Strawberry Shortbread Cookies, 2 oz., 36 pk.
7944.573 out of 5 Stars. 794 reviews4.573 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for ShippingShippingOREO Mini Mix Variety Pack Sandwich Cookies, 1.5 oz., 30 pk., $12.78, $0.28/oz
$1278current price $12.78$0.28/ozOREO Mini Mix Variety Pack Sandwich Cookies, 1.5 oz., 30 pk.
14414.78 out of 5 Stars. 1441 reviews4.78 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for ShippingShippingCHIPS AHOY! Chocolate Chip Cookies, Family Size, 18.2 oz., 3 pk., $10.28, $0.19/oz
$1028current price $10.28$0.19/ozCHIPS AHOY! Chocolate Chip Cookies, Family Size, 18.2 oz., 3 pk.
27104.4919 out of 5 Stars. 2710 reviews4.4919 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for ShippingShippingOREO Chocolate Sandwich Cookies, 5.23 oz., 12 pk., $10.98, $0.17/oz
$1098current price $10.98$0.17/ozOREO Chocolate Sandwich Cookies, 5.23 oz., 12 pk.
120674.8008 out of 5 Stars. 12067 reviews4.8008 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup, Delivery or ShippingPickupDeliveryShippingNutella B-Ready Crispy Wafers, 0.7 oz., 36ct, $13.98, $0.50/oz
$1398current price $13.98$0.50/ozNutella B-Ready Crispy Wafers, 0.7 oz., 36ct
6784.851 out of 5 Stars. 678 reviews4.851 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup, Delivery or ShippingPickupDeliveryShippingKeebler Mini Fudge Stripe Cookies, 2 oz., 36 ct., $13.98, $0.39/ea
$1398current price $13.98$0.39/eaKeebler Mini Fudge Stripe Cookies, 2 oz., 36 ct.
5854.7402 out of 5 Stars. 585 reviews4.7402 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDelivery
About this item
Product details
info:
If the item details above aren't accurate or complete, we want to know about it.Â
Member ratings & reviews
Filtered and sorted results would be available on the new 'Customer ratings & reviews' page.
Sort by |
Showing 1-3 of 738 reviews
Jun 3, 2026
Reviewer name: The Phone Guy
5 out of 5 stars
Verified Purchase
Fantastic value for your dollar!
Just an incredible value! The product was fresh, and you could tell it had been properly stored prior to sale. Very impressive!
Helpful?1IKHE4UIPSA44400002937
Jul 28, 2026
Reviewer name: robgc1
5 out of 5 stars
Verified Purchase
Delicious
Nutter Butters are awesome, great peanut flavor, you won't be disappointed
Helpful?1IKHE4UIPSA44400002937
Aug 23, 2026
Reviewer name: 2517chow
5 out of 5 stars
Verified Purchase
Enough to share with friends/family
Never disappoints. Great price for such a delicious snack.
Helpful?1IKHE4UIPSA44400002937
Popular products in this category
Mott's Assorted Fruit Flavored Snacks, 0.8 oz., 90 pk., $9.98, Was $11.98, $0.14/oz
Instant Savings
SponsoredNow$998current price Now $9.98, Was $11.98$11.98$0.14/oz$2 offEnds Oct 11Mott's Assorted Fruit Flavored Snacks, 0.8 oz., 90 pk.
60384.7635 out of 5 Stars. 6038 reviews4.7635 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup, Delivery or ShippingPickupDeliveryShippingNutella & GO! Hazelnut and Cocoa Spread + Breadsticks, 1.8 oz., 16 pk., $15.98, $0.55/oz
$1598current price $15.98$0.55/ozNutella & GO! Hazelnut and Cocoa Spread + Breadsticks, 1.8 oz., 16 pk.
18544.8382 out of 5 Stars. 1854 reviews4.8382 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup, Delivery or ShippingPickupDeliveryShippingMember's Mark Animal Crackers, 5 lbs., $10.58, $0.13/oz
$1058current price $10.58$0.13/ozMember's Mark Animal Crackers, 5 lbs.
37494.6844 out of 5 Stars. 3749 reviews4.6844 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup, Delivery or ShippingPickupDeliveryShippingLotus Biscoff XL Cookies, 0.9 oz., 48 pk, $10.98
Sponsored$1098current price $10.98Lotus Biscoff XL Cookies, 0.9 oz., 48 pk
Available for ShippingShippingMember's Mark Chocolate Chunk Cookies, 18 ct., $7.48, $0.42/ea
$748current price $7.48$0.42/eaMember's Mark Chocolate Chunk Cookies, 18 ct.
165554.7635 out of 5 Stars. 16555 reviews4.7635 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryNilla Wafers Vanilla Wafer Cookies, 2pk., 15 oz., $8.12, $0.27/oz
$812current price $8.12$0.27/ozNilla Wafers Vanilla Wafer Cookies, 2pk., 15 oz.
56504.6081 out of 5 Stars. 5650 reviews4.6081 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup, Delivery or ShippingPickupDeliveryShippingMember's Mark Cookies Variety Pack, 18 ct., $7.48, $0.42/ea
$748current price $7.48$0.42/eaMember's Mark Cookies Variety Pack, 18 ct.
64294.5343 out of 5 Stars. 6429 reviews4.5343 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryAva Organics Coconut Crispy Rollers, 14.1 oz., $11.22, $0.80/oz
$1122current price $11.22$0.80/ozFrom $11.22Ava Organics Coconut Crispy Rollers, 14.1 oz.
32374.7822 out of 5 Stars. 3237 reviews4.7822 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup, Delivery or ShippingPickupDeliveryShippingMembers Mark Jumbo Gourmet Chocolate Chip and Chunk Cookie Dough, 16 oz., 4pk, $12.42, $0.19/oz
$1242current price $12.42$0.19/ozMembers Mark Jumbo Gourmet Chocolate Chip and Chunk Cookie Dough, 16 oz., 4pk
10964.4443 out of 5 Stars. 1096 reviews4.4443 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryNonni's THINaddictives Cranberry Almond Crisps 15 pk., $7.48, $0.67/oz
$748current price $7.48$0.67/ozNonni's THINaddictives Cranberry Almond Crisps 15 pk.
6974.5294 out of 5 Stars. 697 reviews4.5294 out of 5 starsAvailable for ShippingShippingCooper Street Orange Cranberry Cookies, 18 oz., $5.98, $0.33/oz
$598current price $5.98$0.33/ozCooper Street Orange Cranberry Cookies, 18 oz.
22544.7382 out of 5 Stars. 2254 reviews4.7382 out of 5 starsAvailable for ShippingShippingStrawberries, 2 lbs., $6.97, $3.48/lb
$697current price $6.97$3.48/lbStrawberries, 2 lbs.
396564.4161 out of 5 Stars. 39656 reviews4.4161 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup or DeliveryPickupDeliveryNature's Garden Probiotic Mixed Berry Yoggies 0.7 oz., 24 pk., $10.38, $0.61/oz
$1038current price $10.38$0.61/ozNature's Garden Probiotic Mixed Berry Yoggies 0.7 oz., 24 pk.
31304.7473 out of 5 Stars. 3130 reviews4.7473 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup, Delivery or ShippingPickupDeliveryShippingPepperidge Farm Goldfish Cheddar Crackers, 1.25 oz., 36 pk., $13.14, $0.29/oz
$1314current price $13.14$0.29/ozPepperidge Farm Goldfish Cheddar Crackers, 1.25 oz., 36 pk.
29214.8367 out of 5 Stars. 2921 reviews4.8367 out of 5 starsSNAP EBT eligible, pickup or delivery onlyAvailable for Pickup, Delivery or ShippingPickupDeliveryShippingMember's Mark Ultra Premium 2-Ply Toilet Paper 45 rolls, 235 sheets/roll, $24.76, $0.02/sft
$2476current price $24.76$0.02/sftMember's Mark Ultra Premium 2-Ply Toilet Paper 45 rolls, 235 sheets/roll
1936884.8418 out of 5 Stars. 193688 reviews4.8418 out of 5 starsAvailable for Pickup, Delivery or ShippingPickupDeliveryShipping